What Plants Cannot Be Grown Hydroponically – An Aquarist’S Guide

Written ByHoward Parker

There’s a special kind of magic in watching a plant grow right out of the top of your aquarium, its roots dangling in the water and pulling nutrients from your aquatic ecosystem. It’s a beautiful, living filter. But if you’ve ever tried this, you might have faced the frustrating reality that some plants just… don’t work. You’ve followed all the steps, but that avocado pit rots and the carrot top wilts.

I get it, and I’ve been there. The good news is, it’s not your fault! The truth is that while hydroponics is an incredible technique, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution for every plant on earth. Knowing what plants cannot be grown hydroponically is just as important as knowing which ones can.

I promise this guide will save you from future headaches, wasted time, and wilting plants. We’re going to dive deep into the types of plants that are destined to fail in a water-based system and, most importantly, why they fail. You’ll learn about the plants to avoid, the science behind their needs, and how to use this knowledge to create an even more successful and sustainable aquaponic setup. Let’s get growing—the smart way!

Why Some Plants Just Won’t Work: The Science Behind Hydroponic Failures

Before we list the specific culprits, it helps to understand the “why.” Think of it like choosing the right fish for your tank; you wouldn’t put a saltwater fish in a freshwater setup. Plants have specific environmental needs, and hydroponics, for all its benefits, can’t replicate every condition.

A successful hydroponic system, especially one linked to your aquarium, provides three key things: water, a constant supply of nutrients (thank you, fish waste!), and oxygen for the roots. But some plants need more. Here are the main reasons for failure:

  • Physical Support and Structure: Soil isn’t just dirt; it’s an anchor. It provides the stability for heavy plants and the physical space for certain root types to develop properly. Water alone can’t support a top-heavy stalk or allow a tuber to swell.
  • Root Environment Needs: Not all roots are created equal. Some, like tubers and large taproots, are specifically designed to push through and expand within a solid medium like soil. Submerging them in water often leads to suffocation and rot.
  • Massive Size and Weight: This is a simple matter of physics. A home aquarium system cannot logistically or nutritionally support a 10-foot corn stalk or an apple tree. The sheer weight and sprawling root system are completely impractical.
  • Nutrient Demands: While a well-stocked aquarium is rich in nitrogen, it may not provide the massive amounts of specific macro- and micronutrients that large, fruiting plants demand in the precise ratios they need to thrive.

The Un-growables: A Clear List of What Plants Cannot Be Grown Hydroponically

Alright, let’s get to the main event. Here is your go-to list of plants to steer clear of for your aquarium’s hydroponic garden. This part of our what plants cannot be grown hydroponically guide will save you from the most common mistakes.

Large Root Vegetables and Tubers

This is the number one category that trips people up. It seems so tempting to try and grow a potato or a carrot, but these are almost guaranteed to fail. This is one of the most common problems with what plants cannot be grown hydroponically.

Plants like potatoes, carrots, sweet potatoes, radishes, turnips, and beets need to grow their edible parts underground. They require loose, aerated soil that they can push through as they expand. When you place them in water, two things happen: the developing tuber or root has no medium to grow into, and the submerged part is highly susceptible to rot due to a lack of oxygen and constant moisture. They are simply not adapted for an aquatic life.

Trees and Large Shrubs

This might seem obvious, but it’s worth stating clearly. You cannot grow an oak tree, an apple tree, a pine tree, or even a large rose bush out of your aquarium.

These plants develop incredibly vast and complex woody root systems designed to anchor hundreds of pounds of weight against wind and weather. A hydroponic setup provides zero anchorage. Furthermore, their nutrient and space requirements are far beyond what any home system can provide. Even “dwarf” fruit trees are designed for large pots with soil, not a water-based environment.

Grains and Field Crops

Think about a field of corn or wheat. These plants are tall, heavy, and have dense, fibrous root systems that spread out wide to gather nutrients and provide support. This group includes:

  • Corn
  • Wheat
  • Sunflowers
  • Barley

Corn, for example, is a notoriously heavy feeder that would quickly deplete the nutrients in an aquarium. Its height also makes it incredibly unstable without soil to hold it upright. These crops are built for open fields, not a contained aquatic setup.

Fungi Like Mushrooms

This is a point of biological confusion. Mushrooms are not plants! They are fungi, a completely different kingdom of life. They don’t perform photosynthesis and don’t grow from seeds.

Mushrooms grow from mycelium (a root-like network) that thrives in specific substrates like compost, wood logs, or manure. They require dark, humid conditions and get their energy by breaking down organic matter. Putting a mushroom cap in your hydroponic system will only result in a slimy, rotting mess.

The “Technically Possible, But Not Worth the Headache” Category

Now, for the gray area. Some plants can technically be grown hydroponically, but they require such specialized, large-scale commercial systems that they are effectively impossible and impractical for a home aquarist. Trying them will likely end in frustration.

Melons and Large Vining Fruits

Yes, you can get a watermelon or pumpkin seed to sprout in water. The roots will grow. The problem comes later. These plants produce sprawling vines that can run 20 feet or more and, more importantly, produce incredibly heavy fruit.

Supporting a 15-pound cantaloupe with an elaborate, custom-built trellis system that won’t collapse into your aquarium is a challenge for even the most advanced hobbyist. It’s simply not a practical endeavor and is best left to the soil gardeners.

Certain Legumes with Specific Needs

While some beans and peas do well hydroponically, others have unique growth habits that rely on soil. The best example is the peanut. Peanuts are fascinating because they flower above ground, but the flower stalk (called a “peg”) then grows downward and burrows into the soil, where the peanut pod forms. Without soil to burrow into, you’ll never get any peanuts.

Best Practices for Hydroponic Success: Learning From the Failures

Understanding what plants cannot be grown hydroponically gives us a fantastic blueprint for success. The limitations of those plants highlight the strengths of the ones that thrive! Following these what plants cannot be grown hydroponically best practices will set you on the right path.

  1. Focus on Leaves and Stems: The most successful hydroponic plants are those we grow for their foliage. Think leafy greens like lettuce, spinach, and kale, and herbs like basil, mint, and parsley. Their needs are simple: water, nutrients, and light.
  2. Choose Plants with Simple Root Systems: Avoid anything that needs to form a complex tuber or a massive taproot. Plants with simple, fibrous root balls are perfect for soaking up nutrients directly from the water column.
  3. Consider the Final Size: Before you start, ask yourself: how big will this plant get? A small chili plant or a tomato vine can be managed. A giant sunflower cannot. Stick to plants with a compact and manageable growth habit.
  4. Match the Plant to Your System: Your aquarium is a living ecosystem. The nutrients available are directly related to your fish load and feeding schedule. Fast-growing, hungry plants like lettuce are great for high-stock tanks, while slower herbs might be better for a less-stocked betta tank.

The Eco-Friendly Benefits of Knowing What Not to Grow

Thinking about which plants to avoid isn’t just about preventing personal disappointment; it’s also a more responsible way to engage with the hobby. This approach is key to creating a truly sustainable what plants cannot be grown hydroponically system.

Every failed plant represents wasted resources. You’ve used electricity for your lights, nutrients from your tank, and your own valuable time and effort, only for it to end up in the compost bin. By choosing plants that are naturally suited for hydroponics, you are practicing a more eco-friendly what plants cannot be grown hydroponically method.

Success breeds sustainability. When your system works, you are more likely to stick with it, creating a beautiful, long-term, living filtration system for your aquarium. You avoid the cycle of trial-and-error that wastes both money and biological resources. This is one of the most overlooked benefits of what plants cannot be grown hydroponically knowledge.

Frequently Asked Questions About What Plants Cannot Be Grown Hydroponically

Can I grow a small carrot or potato just for the greens?

Yes, you can! This is a great exception. You can place the top of a carrot or a piece of potato with an “eye” in water, and it will sprout leafy greens. However, you are not growing a new root vegetable; you are simply using the stored energy in the tuber to produce foliage. It’s a fun experiment but won’t yield a new crop.

What about dwarf fruit trees? Are they an exception?

Unfortunately, no. “Dwarf” is a relative term, and these trees still develop extensive, woody root systems that require soil for stability and proper aeration. They are designed for large containers with soil, not for suspension in water. The risk of root rot and instability is extremely high.

I saw someone growing corn hydroponically on YouTube. How?

It is possible, but typically only in massive, commercial-grade deep water culture or drip systems that are hundreds of gallons large and have extensive support structures. These are not comparable to a home aquarium setup. For the 99% of hobbyists, corn is firmly on the “do not attempt” list.

Is there any way to modify my system for root vegetables?

Not in a purely hydroponic way. The closest you could get is a media-based aquaponic system. This involves a separate grow bed filled with an inert medium like expanded clay pebbles or perlite. The aquarium water is pumped through this bed, which provides the physical support needed for roots to form. However, this is a much more complex setup than simply placing a plant on top of your tank.

Your Path to a Thriving Aquaponic Garden

Knowledge is your most powerful tool in the aquarium hobby. Knowing the rules of the road—including the dead ends—is what separates frustration from fulfillment. It can be a little disappointing to learn you can’t grow a potato in your fish tank, but don’t see it as a limitation.

Instead, see it as a clear path forward. By understanding what plants cannot be grown hydroponically, you can stop wasting time on doomed projects and focus all your energy on the dozens of amazing plants that will absolutely thrive in your setup.

Now you have the expert knowledge to choose wisely. Go pick out some beautiful lettuce, fragrant basil, or hardy pothos, and watch your aquarium transform into a lush, productive, and truly sustainable ecosystem. Happy growing!

Howard Parker
Latest posts by Howard Parker (see all)