Fish That Red Eared Slider Won’T Eat: Your Ultimate Survival Guide

Written ByHoward Parker

So, you brought home an adorable red-eared slider, envisioning a vibrant, bustling aquatic community. You pictured your turtle serenely basking while colorful fish darted through the water. But then reality hit, and your prized guppies started disappearing one by one, turning your dream tank into an expensive turtle buffet.

I’ve been there, and I know that frustration. It’s a common story in the aquarium world, but I promise you, a peaceful, shared aquarium is not a myth. You just need the right strategy and the right tank mates.

Welcome to your complete cohabitation guide. We’re going to dive deep into the best fish that red eared slider won’t eat, transforming your tank from a hunting ground into a harmonious ecosystem. I’ll share my personal best practices, from picking the perfect fish to setting up your tank for guaranteed success.

Let’s build that beautiful aquarium you’ve been dreaming of.

Why Your Red-Eared Slider Sees Fish as a Snack

Before we pick out new tank mates, it’s crucial to understand why your turtle is acting this way. It’s not personal; it’s instinct. Red-eared sliders are opportunistic omnivores, especially when they’re young.

In the wild, their diet consists of aquatic plants, insects, tadpoles, and yes, small, slow-moving fish. Your turtle isn’t being mean; it’s simply following millions of years of programming that says, “If it’s small, slow, and fits in my mouth, it’s food.”

Young sliders are particularly carnivorous to fuel their rapid growth. As they mature, their diet shifts to include more vegetation. However, that predatory instinct never truly goes away. Our goal isn’t to change the turtle but to outsmart its instincts by choosing tank mates that don’t fit the “easy meal” profile.

The Golden Rules for Choosing Turtle-Safe Fish

Success in a mixed turtle-and-fish tank comes down to a few core principles. Think of this as your foundational fish that red eared slider won’t eat guide. If a fish candidate doesn’t meet at least two of these criteria, it’s best to leave them at the store.

Rule #1: Speed is Your Best Friend

Red-eared sliders are surprisingly quick, but they are ambush predators, not pursuit hunters. They rely on catching their prey off-guard. Therefore, fish that are incredibly fast, agile, and always on the move are fantastic choices. They can easily evade a turtle’s clumsy lunge.

Rule #2: Size and Shape Matter

This is simple biology. A turtle can’t eat what it can’t fit in its mouth. Avoid small, slender fish like Neon Tetras or guppies. Instead, opt for fish that are deep-bodied (taller from back to belly) or will quickly grow larger than your turtle’s head. This makes them a much less appealing target.

Rule #3: The “Tough Guy” Strategy: Armor and Spines

Some fish come with their own built-in defense mechanisms. Armored catfish, like Plecos, have tough, bony plates that make them difficult to injure. Others, like Corydoras catfish, have sharp pectoral spines they can lock in place. A turtle that gets a painful poke once will likely think twice before trying again.

Rule #4: Occupy Different Zones

A great way to keep fish safe is to choose species that don’t share the same “real estate” as your turtle. Sliders spend a lot of time at the surface, basking, and in the mid-water column. Fast-moving bottom-dwellers or fish that stick to the upper levels of the water can often go unnoticed.

Our Top Picks: The Best Fish That Red-Eared Slider Won’t Eat

Alright, let’s get to the fun part! Based on the rules above, here are my tried-and-true recommendations for fish that have the best chance of thriving alongside your shelled friend. This is your go-to list for finding a fish that red eared slider won’t eat.

Zebra and Giant Danios (The Speedsters)

If there’s a perfect “beginner” fish for a turtle tank, it’s the Danio. Zebra Danios are incredibly fast, hardy, and stick to the top third of the water column. They are simply too quick and erratic for most turtles to bother with. For larger tanks (75+ gallons), their cousins, the Giant Danios, are an even better choice due to their larger size and equally impressive speed.

Rosy Barbs (The Flashy Distraction)

Rosy Barbs are another fantastic option. They are very active swimmers, grow to a decent size (around 4-6 inches), and have a deeper body shape that makes them less of a target. Their peaceful temperament means they won’t bother your turtle, and their constant motion adds beautiful energy to the tank. Just be sure to keep them in a school of at least 5-6 to keep them happy.

Common Plecostomus (The Algae-Eating Armor)

The Common Pleco is a classic choice for a reason: its bony armor makes it nearly indestructible. They are also fantastic algae eaters. But here’s the expert warning: Common Plecos get HUGE, often exceeding 18 inches. They are only suitable for massive tanks (125+ gallons). For smaller setups, a Bristlenose Pleco can work, but you must ensure it has plenty of hiding spots and food, as a starving Pleco might try to suck on a turtle’s shell.

Larger Rainbowfish (The Underrated Gems)

Species like the Boeseman’s Rainbowfish or Turquoise Rainbowfish are excellent candidates. They are peaceful, incredibly fast, and grow large enough to be off the menu. Their stunning, iridescent colors also make them a beautiful centerpiece fish. Like barbs, they are schooling fish and feel most secure in a group.

Cichlids (For Experienced Keepers Only)

This is an advanced option and comes with a big disclaimer. Some of the hardier, faster, and moderately aggressive Central American cichlids, like the Firemouth or Convict Cichlid, can work. They are tough, smart, and can defend themselves. However, this pairing requires a very large tank (100+ gallons) with tons of rockwork and hiding places, and a keeper who is experienced in managing cichlid aggression. Do not attempt this in a smaller tank.

Setting Up Your Tank for Success: A Cohabitation Care Guide

Choosing the right fish is only half the battle. Creating the right environment is what truly guarantees peace. Following these fish that red eared slider won’t eat best practices will give your new additions the best possible chance of survival.

  1. Go Big on Tank Size: This is non-negotiable. A cramped space creates stress and forces unwanted interactions. For a single red-eared slider and a community of fish, a 75-gallon tank is the absolute minimum, with 100+ gallons being ideal. More water volume provides more swimming space and helps keep water parameters stable.
  2. Create a Labyrinth of Hiding Spots: Your fish need safe zones where they can rest and escape if the turtle gets curious. Use driftwood, stacked slate rocks to create caves, and dense plantings (either real or artificial) to break up lines of sight. Anubias and Java Fern are tough live plants that can often withstand a turtle.
  3. Over-Filter Everything: Turtles are incredibly messy. Their waste produces a massive amount of ammonia. You need a filtration system rated for at least twice the size of your actual tank. A powerful canister filter is your best bet. Clean water reduces stress on fish, making them healthier and more alert.
  4. Keep Your Turtle Well-Fed: A hungry turtle is a hunting turtle. Ensure you are feeding your slider a high-quality, varied diet of commercial turtle pellets, leafy greens (like romaine or dandelion greens), and occasional protein treats. A satisfied turtle is far less likely to go looking for a snack.

Common Problems and Proactive Solutions

Even with perfect planning, you might run into issues. Here’s how to troubleshoot some common problems with fish that red eared slider won’t eat.

  • The Problem: My turtle is still chasing the “safe” fish!

    The Solution: First, check your turtle’s diet. Is it getting enough food? Second, add more visual barriers and hiding spots. If the chasing is relentless, the specific turtle may just have an unusually high prey drive, and cohabitation might not be possible for that individual.
  • The Problem: The fish are nipping at my turtle’s skin or tail.

    The Solution: This can happen with some semi-aggressive fish like barbs if they are not kept in a large enough school. It’s a sign of stress. Ensure the school size is appropriate (6+) and the tank is large enough. If it continues, you may need to re-home the offending fish.
  • The Problem: My Pleco is attached to my turtle’s shell!

    The Solution: This is a serious red flag. It almost always means the Pleco is not getting enough to eat. Immediately increase its feedings with sinking algae wafers, blanched zucchini, and ensure there is driftwood in the tank for it to graze on. If the behavior persists, they must be separated to prevent shell infections.

Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Choices for Your Turtle Tank

As responsible aquarists, we should always consider the environmental impact of our hobby. When seeking sustainable fish that red eared slider won’t eat, the best practice is to choose captive-bred fish whenever possible.

Captive-bred fish are hardier, accustomed to aquarium life, and don’t deplete wild populations. Most of the fish recommended above, like Danios, Barbs, and many Rainbowfish, are readily available as captive-bred specimens.

Furthermore, this is a crucial reminder to never release a red-eared slider (or any aquarium pet) into the wild. They are an invasive species in many parts of the world and can cause severe damage to local ecosystems. This is a core part of being an eco-friendly fish that red eared slider won’t eat keeper.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fish That Red-Eared Slider Won’t Eat

Can I keep goldfish or koi with my red-eared slider?

This is a very common question, and the answer is a firm no. Goldfish and koi are members of the carp family and contain high levels of an enzyme called thiaminase. If eaten, this enzyme can lead to a fatal Vitamin B1 deficiency in your turtle. They are also extremely messy, further complicating water quality.

How many fish can I safely add to my turtle tank?

Start slowly! The “one inch of fish per gallon” rule does not apply here because of the turtle’s massive bioload. A good starting point for a 75-gallon tank would be a school of 6-8 Danios or Barbs. After a month, if the water parameters are stable, you could consider adding another small school or a single bottom-dweller. Always prioritize a low stocking level.

What about adding snails or shrimp as a cleanup crew?

You can certainly add them, but you should consider them a food source, not a permanent resident. A red-eared slider will happily devour any snail or shrimp it can find. They are a great, enriching snack for your turtle, but don’t expect them to last long!

Do I really need to quarantine new fish before adding them?

Absolutely, 100% yes. A quarantine tank is your single best defense against introducing diseases like Ich into your main display tank. All new fish should be observed in a separate 10-gallon tank for at least 2-4 weeks before being introduced to your turtle’s home. It may seem like extra work, but it can save you from a total system wipeout.

Your Journey to a Harmonious Aquarium

Creating a thriving community tank with a red-eared slider is a truly rewarding challenge. It requires more planning and a bigger setup than a standard fish-only aquarium, but the result is a dynamic, fascinating ecosystem that you can be proud of.

Remember the key takeaways: choose fast, deep-bodied, or armored fish. Provide a massive, well-filtered tank with plenty of hiding places. And keep your turtle fat and happy with a proper diet. By following this guide, you’re no longer guessing; you’re making informed choices based on sound aquatic principles.

Now you have the knowledge and the confidence to build that stunning aquarium you first imagined. Go forth and create something beautiful!

Howard Parker
Latest posts by Howard Parker (see all)