Creeping Jenny Vs Moneywort – Which Lush Green Carpet Is Right

Written ByHoward Parker

Have you ever stood in front of a wall of aquarium plants, dreaming of creating a vibrant, lush green carpet in your tank? You grab two pots that look strikingly similar—both with charming, rounded green leaves—labeled Creeping Jenny and Moneywort. They seem almost identical, but you’ve heard whispers in forums that they are worlds apart.

You’re not alone in this confusion. It’s one of the most common mix-ups for aquarists, and choosing the wrong one can lead to a melted, disappointing mess. But don’t worry, I’m here to clear the air for you.

I promise that by the end of this guide, you’ll understand the crucial differences between these two green beauties. You’ll be able to confidently walk into any fish store and pick the exact plant that will thrive in your specific setup.

We’ll dive deep into a side-by-side comparison, explore their unique care needs, uncover the best aquascaping uses for each, and troubleshoot common problems. Let’s unravel the great creeping jenny vs moneywort debate and get you on the path to a stunning planted aquarium.

Meet the Contenders: A Closer Look at Creeping Jenny and Moneywort

Before we pit them against each other, let’s get properly acquainted. While they may look like twins from a distance, understanding their individual identities is the first step in our creeping jenny vs moneywort guide.

Creeping Jenny (Lysimachia nummularia): The Golden Terrestrial

Creeping Jenny, especially the ‘Aurea’ or golden variety, is famous in the gardening world. It’s a stunning, fast-growing ground cover for ponds, bogs, and damp garden beds. Its calling card is its bright, chartreuse to yellow, coin-shaped leaves that create a brilliant mat of color.

Because it loves moisture, it’s often sold in pet stores as a true aquatic plant. Here’s the secret, though: it’s actually a marginal plant. This means it loves having its roots wet but prefers its leaves out of the water. It can survive submerged for a few months, but it rarely thrives long-term.

Moneywort (Bacopa monnieri): The True Aquatic Workhorse

Moneywort, on the other hand, is a true aquatic plant. This is the most critical distinction. It has spent its entire evolutionary history growing fully submerged in the marshes and wetlands of the world. It’s an incredibly reliable and versatile stem plant.

Its leaves are a bit more oval-shaped than Creeping Jenny’s and typically a deeper, richer green. In the aquarium hobby, Bacopa monnieri is a beloved classic, known for its easy-going nature and steady growth.

Creeping Jenny vs Moneywort: A Head-to-Head Comparison

Now for the main event. Let’s break down the key differences so you can see exactly how these two plants stack up. This is where you’ll find the most important creeping jenny vs moneywort tips.

Appearance and Growth Habit

At first glance, they both have rounded leaves on a stem. But look closer.

  • Creeping Jenny: Features perfectly round, coin-like leaves. Its color is a vibrant, electric light green or even yellow. Submerged, it tries to grow low and “creep,” but often struggles and sends out leggy, sparse stems reaching for the surface.
  • Moneywort: Has slightly more elongated, spade-shaped, or oval leaves. The color is a more classic, deep shade of green. It grows as a classic stem plant, straight up towards the light, but can be trained to grow into a dense bush or carpet with proper trimming.

Lighting and CO2 Requirements

Their needs under the water are quite different, which is a major factor in their long-term success.

  • Creeping Jenny: To even stand a chance submerged, it demands high light and CO2 injection. Without intense conditions, it will quickly shed its lower leaves, become leggy, and eventually melt away.
  • Moneywort: This plant is far more forgiving. It does well in low to medium light and requires no supplemental CO2 to grow. Of course, it will grow faster, denser, and more vibrant with higher light and CO2, making it perfect for both beginners and advanced aquascapers.

Substrate and Planting

How you plant them is straightforward, but their response to being planted is where they differ.

  • Creeping Jenny: You plant it like any other stem plant, pushing the stems into the substrate. However, because it’s not a true aquatic, its root system often fails to establish properly underwater, contributing to its eventual decline.
  • Moneywort: Plant individual stems about an inch apart in your substrate. It will quickly develop a robust root system and anchor itself firmly, drawing nutrients and preparing for lush vertical growth.

The Most Important Difference: True Aquatic vs. Marginal

If you take only one thing from this article, let it be this: Moneywort is an aquatic plant, and Creeping Jenny is not.

Think of it like this: a polar bear can survive for a little while in a warm forest, but it won’t be happy or healthy. Eventually, it will fail. Creeping Jenny is the polar bear in your tropical aquarium. It’s built for a different environment (the edge of a pond), and while it can tolerate being submerged for a while, it’s not a sustainable, long-term choice. This is the core of our sustainable creeping jenny vs moneywort discussion.

Best Practices for Moneywort (Bacopa monnieri): Your Go-To Green

Since Moneywort is the clear winner for most aquariums, let’s focus on a simple care guide to help you succeed. It’s one of the most rewarding plants for beginners!

Ideal Water Parameters

Moneywort is wonderfully adaptable. You don’t need to stress over its conditions.

  • Temperature: 72-82°F (22-28°C)
  • pH: 6.0-7.5
  • Lighting: Low to high. More light equals denser, faster growth.
  • CO2: Not required, but always appreciated.

Planting for a Lush Carpet or Bush

Want that dense, bushy look? The secret is in the trim. Here’s how to creeping jenny vs moneywort planting and trimming should be approached—focus on the Moneywort!

  1. Plant each stem individually, about one inch deep into the substrate. Space them about an inch apart.
  2. Let them grow a few inches towards the light.
  3. Once they are established, trim the top 2-3 inches off each stem.
  4. Replant the trimmed tops right next to the original stems!

By repeating this process, you’ll quickly turn a few sparse stems into a dense, beautiful green forest or midground bush. It’s one of the greatest benefits of creeping jenny vs moneywort—the latter’s ability to propagate so easily.

The Truth About Creeping Jenny (Lysimachia nummularia) in Aquariums

So, is Creeping Jenny completely useless for aquariums? Not at all! You just have to use it correctly. This is where we discuss some common problems with creeping jenny vs moneywort and how to use Creeping Jenny in an eco-friendly way.

Can It Truly Thrive Submerged?

In 95% of aquariums, the answer is no. It will look amazing for the first month or two, tricking you into thinking you’ve succeeded. Then, slowly but surely, it will begin to thin out, drop leaves, and rot from the bottom up. It’s not your fault; it’s just the plant’s biology.

Best Uses: Play to Its Strengths!

To use Creoping Jenny sustainably, use it where it’s meant to be!

  • Paludariums: This is its perfect home! Plant it in the terrestrial, boggy sections of a paludarium where its roots can stay wet and its leaves can grow in the open air.
  • Emersed Growth: It looks incredible draped over driftwood or rocks that stick out of the water. The leaves will cascade down towards the water’s surface, creating a stunning effect.
  • Pond Edges: If you have an outdoor pond, it’s a fantastic, hardy groundcover for the edges.

Common Problems and Troubleshooting Your Greenery

Even with easy plants like Moneywort, you can run into a few bumps. Here’s a quick troubleshooting guide.

“My Moneywort is Getting Leggy and Sparse!”

This is almost always a lighting issue. “Leggy” growth, where there are large gaps between sets of leaves, means the plant is stretching desperately for more light. Try increasing your light intensity or the duration it’s on for. Regular trimming also encourages side shoots, leading to bushier growth.

“My Creeping Jenny is Melting and Dying!”

This isn’t a problem to solve; it’s the natural outcome of keeping a non-aquatic plant fully submerged. It’s reached the end of its underwater lifespan. Your best bet is to remove the dying stems and try using it in an emersed setup next time.

“There’s Algae Growing on the Leaves!”

This can happen to any slow-to-moderate growing plant. It’s a sign of an imbalance in your tank, usually too much light, too many nutrients in the water column, or not enough CO2. Reduce your lighting period, ensure you have a good cleanup crew (like Amano shrimp or snails), and stay on top of water changes.

Frequently Asked Questions About Creeping Jenny vs Moneywort

Which plant is better for a low-tech, no-CO2 aquarium?

Moneywort (Bacopa monnieri) is the undeniable winner here. It is perfectly happy in low-tech setups and will grow steadily without any special equipment, making it an ideal choice for beginners.

Can I plant Creeping Jenny and Moneywort together in the same tank?

You can, but it’s not recommended for a fully submerged setup. The Moneywort will thrive while the Creeping Jenny will likely struggle and die off, leading to decaying plant matter that can foul your water. If you have a setup with an emersed section, you could plant Moneywort in the water and Creeping Jenny on the land portion.

How fast do these plants grow?

Under ideal conditions (good light, nutrients, and CO2), both are considered fast growers. However, in a typical beginner’s aquarium, Moneywort will grow at a steady, moderate pace, while Creeping Jenny’s growth will be temporary before it begins to decline.

Is Creeping Jenny ‘Aurea’ different from regular Creeping Jenny?

‘Aurea’ simply refers to the golden-colored cultivar of Lysimachia nummularia. It’s the variety most commonly sold in the aquarium trade due to its striking color. Its care requirements and limitations are identical to the standard green version.

The Final Verdict: Choose for Long-Term Success

So, when it comes to the creeping jenny vs moneywort showdown, the choice for a fully underwater aquascape is crystal clear. Moneywort (Bacopa monnieri) is the reliable, hardy, and truly aquatic plant that will reward you with lush, green growth for years to come.

Creeping Jenny (Lysimachia nummularia), while beautiful, is a terrestrial plant in aquatic clothing. Reserve its stunning golden leaves for paludariums, emersed features, and pond edges where it can truly shine.

Understanding the fundamental nature of your plants is the secret to a successful aquascape. You now have the expert knowledge to avoid a common pitfall and choose the right green for your scene. Go forth and grow that beautiful underwater garden you’ve been dreaming of!

Howard Parker
Latest posts by Howard Parker (see all)
Related posts
  • Is Golden Moneywort Poisonous To Dogs – A Pet-Safe Aquarist’S
  • Does A Moneywort Plant Flower Under Water – Unlocking The Secrets