Cinnamon Clownfish Vs Tomato Clownfish: Which Bold Beauty Is Right
Staring into a fish store tank, you see two vibrant, reddish-orange clownfish. They look similar, they’re both gorgeous, and now you’re stuck. Is that a Cinnamon Clownfish? Or is it a Tomato? And more importantly, which one is the right fit for your home aquarium?
Don’t worry, you’ve come to the right place! As fellow aquarists at Aquifarm, we’ve guided countless hobbyists through this exact decision. This comprehensive guide will break down the crucial differences between these two species, from their looks and personality to their specific care needs.
We’ll dive deep into the cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish debate, covering their appearance, temperament, tank requirements, and even their preferred anemone partners. By the end of this guide, you’ll feel confident and excited to choose the perfect fiery-hued friend for your underwater world.
Meet the Contenders: A Quick Introduction to Cinnamon and Tomato Clowns
Before we pit them against each other, let’s get properly acquainted. Both fish belong to the Amphiprion genus, the group we all know and love as clownfish. They share a similar body shape and that classic, endearing clownfish wobble.
The Cinnamon Clownfish (Amphiprion melanopus) is also known as the Red and Black Anemonefish or the Fire Clownfish. The name gives you a hint—it boasts a deep, spicy reddish-orange color that can darken to near-black on its lower body and fins, especially as it matures.
The Tomato Clownfish (Amphiprion frenatus) is another stunning specimen. It typically has a brighter, more uniform tomato-red or orange-red coloration across its entire body. It’s one of the most iconic and recognizable members of the clownfish family after the Ocellaris.
Appearance Showdown: Telling Them Apart at a Glance
At first glance, they can be tricky to distinguish, especially as juveniles. But once you know what to look for, telling them apart becomes much easier. Here’s a simple breakdown.
The Head Stripe
This is the most reliable way to tell them apart. Both fish have a single, vertical white stripe right behind their eye.
- Cinnamon Clownfish (A. melanopus): The head stripe is wide and often has a distinct, thin blueish outline, especially on younger fish. It’s a subtle but beautiful detail.
- Tomato Clownfish (A. frenatus): The head stripe is typically narrower and a crisp, pure white. It lacks that blueish tinge. As male Tomato Clownfish mature, this stripe can sometimes fade or even disappear entirely.
Coloration and Fins
Their body color and fin patterns are the next big clue. This is where the “cinnamon” name really makes sense.
- Cinnamon Clownfish: They have a deep, burnt-orange body. The key identifier is their fins. Their pelvic and anal fins (the bottom fins) are jet black. This strong contrast with their fiery body is a dead giveaway.
- Tomato Clownfish: They have a more consistent, bright “tomato soup” red. Their fins are typically the same red-orange color as their body, lacking the distinct black markings of the Cinnamon Clown.
Size Differences
While not always obvious in a store, there is a general size difference. Cinnamons tend to be slightly larger and bulkier than their Tomato cousins.
- Cinnamon Clownfish: Can reach up to 4.5 inches (about 11 cm).
- Tomato Clownfish: Usually top out around 4 inches (about 10 cm), though some large females can get bigger.
The Big Question: Temperament and Aggression Levels
Okay, this is arguably the most important section. A fish’s personality determines the harmony of your entire tank. In the cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish showdown, temperament is a major deciding factor.
Let’s be clear: both of these fish are on the more aggressive end of the clownfish spectrum. They are not gentle like Ocellaris or Percula clowns. They are bold, territorial, and will defend their space (and their anemone) with vigor. However, there are nuances.
Cinnamon Clownfish Temperament
Cinnamon Clownfish are known for being very territorial and aggressive, especially established females. They are often considered one of the more pugnacious clownfish species available. They will actively defend a large portion of the tank as their own and may bully more timid fish.
If you plan to keep a Cinnamon, it’s often best to add it to the tank last. This prevents it from establishing a massive territory before other, more peaceful fish can get settled. They can be kept with other semi-aggressive fish that can hold their own, like certain dottybacks, damsels (with caution), and wrasses.
Tomato Clownfish Temperament
Tomato Clownfish are also quite assertive, but generally considered a small step down in aggression from Cinnamons. A large female will still be the undisputed boss of the tank, but they are often a bit more “bark” than “bite” compared to a feisty Cinnamon.
They are still much more aggressive than an Ocellaris and will chase away fish that venture too close to their home. They do best in a tank with other robust fish. Don’t even think about housing them with super shy or delicate species like firefish.
Cinnamon Clownfish vs Tomato Clownfish: A Detailed Care Guide
Here’s where we get into the nitty-gritty. Fortunately, the benefits of cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish care are that both are incredibly hardy and great for aquarists who are ready to move beyond the most common beginner fish. This is your complete cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish care guide.
Tank Size and Setup
Because of their size and territorial nature, a standard nano tank won’t cut it for these guys. Giving them enough space is one of the most important cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish best practices to manage aggression.
- For a single fish or a bonded pair: A minimum of a 30-gallon tank is recommended. This gives them enough room to establish a territory without feeling constantly pressured.
- For a community tank: You’ll want to go larger, 55 gallons or more, to give other fish plenty of swimming room to escape the clown’s territory.
Plenty of live rock with caves and crevices is essential. This breaks up sightlines and gives other fish places to hide, which is crucial for a peaceful tank.
Water Parameters
Both fish are quite forgiving, a huge plus for beginners! They are almost always aquacultured now, meaning they are well-adapted to standard aquarium conditions. Aim for stability over chasing perfect numbers.
- Temperature: 75-82°F (24-28°C)
- Salinity: 1.023-1.026 specific gravity
- pH: 8.1-8.4
- Ammonia/Nitrite: 0 ppm
- Nitrate: <20 ppm
Diet and Feeding
These clowns are enthusiastic eaters! They are omnivores and will accept almost anything you offer them. A varied diet is key to their health and vibrant coloration.
A good feeding plan includes:
- A high-quality marine pellet or flake food as a daily staple.
- Frozen foods like mysis shrimp, brine shrimp, and spirulina-enriched preparations 2-3 times a week.
- Occasional meaty foods like chopped krill or table shrimp for a treat.
Feed them small amounts once or twice a day, only what they can consume in about a minute. This prevents waste and keeps your water quality high.
Anemone Compatibility: Finding the Perfect Host
Watching a clownfish nestle into a host anemone is one of the most magical sights in the hobby. If this is your goal, choosing the right anemone is critical.
Here’s some good news: both the Cinnamon and Tomato Clownfish are less picky than other species and will readily host a variety of anemones. Their top choice in the wild is the Bubble Tip Anemone (Entacmaea quadricolor), which is also the hardiest and most recommended anemone for aquarium life. It’s a perfect match!
Other potential hosts include:
- Sebae Anemone (Heteractis crispa)
- Carpet Anemones (Stichodactyla sp.) – Use caution, these can eat fish and require expert care.
A pro tip: Don’t worry if your clownfish doesn’t take to an anemone right away. It can take days, weeks, or even months. Sometimes they ignore it completely! The fish does not need an anemone to thrive in an aquarium, especially if it was captive-bred.
Sustainable Choices: Eco-Friendly Clownfish Best Practices
At Aquifarm, we believe in a beautiful hobby that’s also a responsible one. When considering a sustainable cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish, the answer is simple: always choose captive-bred.
Years ago, nearly all marine fish were wild-caught, which put immense pressure on coral reefs. Today, the vast majority of Cinnamon and Tomato Clownfish on the market are commercially aquacultured. This is a huge win for the environment and for you!
Benefits of Captive-Bred Clownfish:
- More Hardy: They are raised on aquarium foods and are already accustomed to tank life.
- Less Aggressive: While still assertive, captive-bred individuals are often slightly less aggressive than their wild counterparts.
- Eco-Friendly: Choosing captive-bred fish leaves wild populations on the reef where they belong.
- Disease-Free: They are far less likely to carry common marine parasites or diseases.
When you buy your fish, ask the store if they are captive-bred. Supporting these eco-friendly cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish options is one of the best things we can do as hobbyists.
The Final Verdict: Which Clownfish Should You Choose?
So, after comparing them side-by-side, which one belongs in your tank? Let’s distill this cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish guide into a final recommendation.
Choose the Cinnamon Clownfish if:
- You love its deep, burnt-orange color and striking black fins.
- You have a larger tank (40G+) and are prepared for a truly bold, assertive fish.
- Your tank contains other semi-aggressive fish that won’t be easily intimidated.
- You want the “boss” of the tank to be a stunning, fiery centerpiece.
Choose the Tomato Clownfish if:
- You prefer a brighter, more uniform cherry-red coloration.
- You want a bold clownfish, but are looking for a personality that’s a small step down from the Cinnamon.
- Your tank is 30 gallons or larger and you want a hardy, confident fish.
- You are a beginner-to-intermediate aquarist looking for your first “aggressive” clownfish experience.
Ultimately, both are fantastic, hardy, and beautiful fish. Your choice comes down to a preference in aesthetics and what level of aggression your specific aquarium setup can handle.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cinnamon Clownfish vs Tomato Clownfish
Can I keep a Cinnamon and a Tomato Clownfish together?
No, this is not recommended. Both species are highly territorial and belong to the same “complex” of clownfish. They would see each other as direct competitors and would likely fight, potentially to the death. It’s best to stick to one species per tank.
Are Cinnamon and Tomato Clownfish good for beginners?
They are excellent for adventurous beginners. While they are as hardy and easy to feed as an Ocellaris Clownfish, their aggression requires more planning regarding tank size and tank mates. If you’ve done your research and are prepared for their personality, they can be a wonderful and rewarding first clownfish.
Do I absolutely need an anemone for these clownfish?
Not at all! This is a common myth. Captive-bred clownfish have never seen an anemone and do not require one to live a happy, healthy life in an aquarium. They will often “host” other things, like a powerhead, a large coral, or even a corner of the tank. Anemones are beautiful but require specific lighting and care that is often more demanding than the fish itself.
What are common problems with Cinnamon Clownfish vs Tomato Clownfish?
The most common problem is underestimating their aggression. Hobbyists sometimes add them to a peaceful community tank and are surprised when the clown starts bullying other fish. The other issue is Brooklynella (Clownfish Disease), though this is much rarer in captive-bred fish. Always quarantine new arrivals to be safe. Otherwise, they are remarkably disease-resistant and trouble-free fish.
We hope this definitive guide on how to choose between a cinnamon clownfish vs tomato clownfish has armed you with the knowledge and confidence you need. Both of these fish are jewels of the marine world, and with the right setup, either one will bring years of enjoyment and personality to your aquarium.
Now that you know the difference, the fun part begins. Go forth, plan your tank, and get ready to welcome your new fiery friend home!
- Will Axolotl Jump Out Of Tank – Preventing Escapes & Ensuring Your - January 7, 2026
- How Do Axolotls Mate – A Comprehensive Guide To Successful Breeding - January 7, 2026
- Axolotl Curled Tail – Understanding, Preventing, And Nurturing Healthy - January 7, 2026