Cherry Shrimp Vs Amano Shrimp: Your Ultimate Guide To Choosing
So, you’re standing in front of your aquarium, admiring your work. The plants are green, the fish are happy, but there’s just one thing missing: a dedicated cleanup crew to tackle that pesky algae and leftover food. You’ve heard the names whispered in fish stores and online forums—Cherry Shrimp and Amano Shrimp. But which one is right for your tank?
I get it. Making this choice can feel overwhelming. One offers a brilliant splash of color, while the other is a legendary, tireless worker. Don’t worry, you’ve come to the right place. As a long-time aquarist, I’ve kept both of these amazing critters for years, and I’m here to help you make the perfect decision.
In this complete cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp guide, we’re going to break down everything you need to know. We’ll compare their appearance, algae-eating prowess, temperament, and care needs. By the end, you’ll be able to choose your new tank janitors with total confidence, creating a healthier and more beautiful aquarium.
Meet the Contenders: A Quick Introduction
Before we dive deep, let’s get formally acquainted with our two invertebrates. Think of this as meeting the candidates for the most important job in your aquarium—Head of Sanitation!
The Colorful Colonizer: Cherry Shrimp (Neocaridina davidi)
Cherry Shrimp are the darlings of the nano tank world, and for good reason! These tiny, vibrant shrimp bring a stunning pop of red to any aquascape. They are dwarf shrimp, meaning they stay small and are incredibly peaceful.
What makes them so popular with beginners is their hardiness and willingness to breed. If you provide them with a stable, happy home, you’ll soon have a self-sustaining colony that works around the clock, grazing on biofilm and soft algae. They are the perfect little residents for a peaceful, planted tank.
The Algae-Eating Powerhouse: Amano Shrimp (Caridina multidentata)
Named after the legendary aquascaper Takashi Amano, who popularized their use, Amano Shrimp are the special forces of algae control. They are larger, more robust, and have an insatiable appetite for many types of algae that other critters ignore.
While they may not have the bright colors of Cherries, their translucent, dotted bodies have a subtle beauty. They are true workhorses, constantly scouring every surface of your tank. If your primary goal is a spotless aquarium, the Amano Shrimp is an unrivaled champion.
Appearance and Size: Spot the Difference Instantly
One of the most obvious differences between these two shrimp is how they look. Your choice here often comes down to personal aesthetic preference—do you want a splash of color or a more functional, camouflaged cleaner?
Cherry Shrimp: A Living Splash of Color
The most defining feature of the Cherry Shrimp is its brilliant red coloration. However, they come in a whole rainbow of colors thanks to selective breeding, including blue, yellow, green, and even black! They are graded based on the intensity and coverage of their color, from pale “regular” Cherries to deep, solid “Fire Red” or “Painted Fire Red” grades.
- Size: Adults typically reach about 1 to 1.5 inches (2.5-4 cm).
- Color: Most famously red, but available in many other colors.
- Appearance: Small, delicate, and brightly colored, making them a beautiful ornamental addition.
Amano Shrimp: The Ghostly Worker
Amano Shrimp have a more utilitarian look. Their bodies are mostly transparent, grayish, or have a light brownish-green tint. Their signature feature is a line of small, dark dots or dashes running along their sides.
Their larger size makes them more noticeable in the tank, and you can really see them get to work. Their understated appearance allows your plants and fish to be the stars of the show, while they work tirelessly in the background. This is a key part of our cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp guide; aesthetics matter!
- Size: Significantly larger, reaching up to 2 inches (5 cm) or even a bit more.
- Color: Translucent with a pattern of dots or dashes.
- Appearance: Robust, energetic, and built for work.
The Great Algae Debate: Who Cleans Better?
Let’s get to the main event: algae eating! Both shrimp are excellent cleaners, but they specialize in different areas. Understanding the benefits of cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp in this category is crucial for a clean tank.
Cherry Shrimp: The Gentle Grazer
Cherry Shrimp are fantastic for daily maintenance. They are constantly picking at surfaces, consuming biofilm (a mix of bacteria and microorganisms), soft green algae, and leftover fish food. A colony of Cherries can keep a small to medium-sized tank looking pristine by preventing algae from ever taking hold.
However, they are not heavy-duty algae eaters. They will generally ignore tougher algae like Black Beard Algae (BBA) or Green Spot Algae. Think of them as the team that keeps the house tidy day-to-day.
Amano Shrimp: The Demolition Crew
This is where the Amano Shrimp truly shines. Their appetite is legendary. They will devour soft algae, hair algae, and even some tougher types that Cherries won’t touch. They are one of the few creatures in the hobby known to eat Black Beard Algae, especially when it’s young.
If you have a visible algae problem you need to solve, a small group of Amanos will make a dramatic difference in just a few weeks. They are the specialists you call in for the tough jobs. If you’re looking for how to cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp can solve your algae woes, Amanos are often the more powerful solution.
Temperament and Tank Mates: Creating a Peaceful Community
Both shrimp are peaceful, but their size and behavior create different considerations when choosing tank mates. This is one of the most important cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp best practices to follow for a harmonious aquarium.
Cherry Shrimp: Small and Vulnerable
Because they are so small, Cherry Shrimp are potential snacks for a wide variety of fish. Even fish you might not consider aggressive, like larger Tetras or a Betta, might hunt them. Their tiny babies (shrimplets) are especially vulnerable.
Ideal Tank Mates:
- Small Rasboras (like Chili or Phoenix)
- Pygmy Corydoras
- Otocinclus Catfish
- Other dwarf shrimp and snails
A heavily planted tank with lots of moss provides crucial hiding spots for adults and shrimplets, increasing their survival rate in a community setting.
Amano Shrimp: Bold and Confident
Amanos are larger, faster, and much more assertive. They can hold their own with a wider range of peaceful community fish. They are excellent at snatching food, sometimes even zipping away with an algae wafer right from under a fish’s nose! This boldness makes them less likely to be seen as food.
Ideal Tank Mates:
- Most Tetras, Rasboras, and Danios
- Gouramis (avoiding larger, more aggressive types)
- Corydoras Catfish
- Bettas (with caution, depends on the Betta’s personality)
They are generally safe with most peaceful community fish that aren’t large enough to swallow them whole. Just be sure to avoid cichlids, large barbs, or other notoriously aggressive fish.
Breeding: The Prolific vs. The Nearly Impossible
This is perhaps the single biggest difference between the two species and a major deciding factor for many aquarists. Do you want a thriving, self-sustaining colony, or are you just looking for a cleanup crew?
Cherry Shrimp: Effortless Breeding
Cherry Shrimp are incredibly easy to breed in a home aquarium. If you have males and females and stable water conditions, they will reproduce. The females carry bright yellow eggs under their tails for about 30 days before hatching fully formed, miniature versions of themselves.
Watching a colony grow from a small group of ten to a bustling city of hundreds is one of the most rewarding experiences in the hobby. This makes them a wonderfully sustainable cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp choice, as you’ll never need to buy more. It’s a truly eco-friendly cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp option.
Amano Shrimp: A Complex Challenge
Amano Shrimp will readily carry eggs in a freshwater tank, but the larvae will not survive. In nature, the larvae are washed downstream into the ocean, where they develop in brackish or full saltwater before migrating back to freshwater as shrimplets.
Replicating this process at home is extremely difficult and requires a separate, dedicated saltwater setup. For 99% of hobbyists, Amano Shrimp will not successfully reproduce in their aquarium. This means the number you buy is the number you’ll have, and all Amanos sold in stores are wild-caught.
The Ideal Home: A Cherry Shrimp vs Amano Shrimp Care Guide
Both shrimp are relatively hardy, but they have specific needs to thrive. Following this cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp care guide will ensure your new pets live long, healthy lives.
Shared Requirements
- Water Parameters: Both prefer stable, clean water. Avoid ammonia and nitrite, and keep nitrates low. A cycled tank is a must.
- Temperature: A range of 70-78°F (21-25.5°C) is great for both.
- Diet: Both are scavengers. They will eat algae, biofilm, and leftover fish food. Supplement their diet with high-quality shrimp pellets or algae wafers a few times a week.
- Molting: Both shrimp molt to grow. You may find their empty exoskeletons (sheds) in the tank. Leave them in, as the shrimp will consume them to reclaim valuable minerals.
- Copper Sensitivity: CRITICAL! Both shrimp are extremely sensitive to copper. Never use medications containing copper in a shrimp tank.
Specific Needs & Common Problems
One of the most common problems with cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp is failing to meet their slightly different environmental needs.
For Cherry Shrimp:
- Tank Size: A 5-gallon tank is a good minimum for a starting colony.
- Hiding Places: Essential for breeding success and security. Java moss, cholla wood, and other dense plants are perfect.
- Water Hardness: They need some minerals (GH and KH) in the water to build their shells properly. If your tap water is very soft, you may need to use a remineralizer.
For Amano Shrimp:
- Tank Size: Due to their larger size and active nature, a 10-gallon tank is a better minimum.
- Food Security: They are voracious eaters. In a very clean tank, you must supplement their diet regularly to prevent them from starving.
- Escape Artists: They are known to climb out of aquariums, so a tight-fitting lid is highly recommended!
Frequently Asked Questions About Cherry Shrimp vs Amano Shrimp
Can I keep Cherry Shrimp and Amano Shrimp together?
Absolutely! This is a fantastic combination. The Amanos handle the heavy-duty algae cleaning, while the Cherries take care of the fine-tuning and add a beautiful splash of color. Since Amanos can’t breed in freshwater, they pose no threat to the Cherry Shrimp colony’s growth.
Which shrimp is better for beginners?
Both are excellent for beginners, but for slightly different reasons. Cherry Shrimp are fantastic if you want the joy of breeding and creating a colony. Amano Shrimp are better if your primary goal is powerful, no-fuss algae control. For a first-time shrimp keeper, Cherries are often recommended due to their simple life cycle.
How many shrimp should I get?
For Cherry Shrimp, start with a group of at least 10 to ensure you have both males and females for breeding. For Amano Shrimp, a group of 3-5 is a great start for a 10-20 gallon tank. You can add more for larger tanks or more severe algae issues.
Will Amano Shrimp eat my Cherry Shrimp?
This is a very rare occurrence. A healthy Amano Shrimp will not hunt a healthy Cherry Shrimp. However, like any scavenger, they are opportunistic. If a Cherry Shrimp is sick, dying, or already dead, an Amano may eat it. This is simply part of nature’s cleanup process and not a sign of aggression.
The Final Verdict: Which Shrimp is Right for You?
By now, you should have a clear picture of what each of these incredible invertebrates brings to the table. The choice in the great cherry shrimp vs amano shrimp debate really comes down to your personal goals for your aquarium.
Choose Cherry Shrimp if:
- You want to add a vibrant splash of color to your tank.
- You are excited by the idea of breeding and growing a self-sustaining colony.
- You have a smaller tank (5-10 gallons).
- Your tank has only very small, peaceful tank mates (or will be a shrimp-only tank).
- Your algae issue is minor and you’re focused on prevention.
Choose Amano Shrimp if:
- Your number one priority is wiping out stubborn algae.
- You have a community tank with fish that might bully or eat smaller Cherry Shrimp.
- You prefer a more natural, understated look for your cleanup crew.
- You are not interested in breeding shrimp.
- You have a secure lid on your aquarium!
Ultimately, there is no wrong answer here. Both shrimp are fascinating, useful, and rewarding additions to the aquarium hobby. Whether you choose the colorful Cherry, the hardworking Amano, or even a mix of both, you’re taking a wonderful step toward a more balanced and beautiful underwater world.
Now go forth, choose your cleanup crew with confidence, and enjoy your sparkling clean tank!
- Dwc Hydroponics System – Your Guide To Lush, Aquarium-Powered Growth - December 4, 2025
- Hydroponics Without Rockwool: The Ultimate Eco-Friendly Guide For - December 4, 2025
- 10 X 20 Rockwool Cubes For Hydroponics – Your Ultimate Guide To A - December 4, 2025