Arowana Fish Vs Goldfish – Choosing Your Next Aquatic Masterpiece

Written ByHoward Parker

Hey there, fellow aquarist! Have you ever found yourself gazing into an aquarium, captivated by the majestic glide of a large, ancient-looking fish, or charmed by the playful darting of a plump, golden companion? It’s a common daydream for many of us, but when it comes to bringing these dreams to life, the choice between an arowana fish vs goldfish can feel like comparing apples to… well, exotic dragons! Both are iconic, but they represent vastly different journeys in the aquarium hobby.

You’re probably here because you’re weighing your options, wondering which of these incredible creatures would be the best fit for your home and lifestyle. Don’t worry, you’re not alone in this delightful dilemma! I’ve been there, and I’m here to promise you that by the end of this comprehensive guide, you’ll have a clear understanding of what it takes to care for each, armed with all the essential arowana fish vs goldfish tips you’ll need.

We’ll dive deep into everything from their size and tank requirements to their diets, temperaments, and even the long-term commitment each fish demands. Get ready to explore the fascinating world of these aquatic wonders and discover which one truly calls to your aquarist’s heart!

The Aquatic Giants and Golden Companions: An Overview

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty, let’s get a general feel for our two contenders. On one side, we have the arowana – often called the “dragon fish.” These are truly magnificent, prehistoric-looking predators that command attention with their shimmering scales and powerful, undulating movements. They’re a symbol of wealth and good fortune in many cultures, and owning one is an experience unlike any other.

On the other side, we have the humble goldfish. But don’t let their ubiquity fool you! These aren’t just carnival prizes. Goldfish, especially the fancy varieties, are intelligent, long-lived, and incredibly personable fish that can bring immense joy to any aquarist. They come in a stunning array of shapes, sizes, and colors, offering a different kind of beauty and interaction.

This isn’t just a comparison of two fish; it’s a comparison of two distinct aquarium experiences. Our goal with this arowana fish vs goldfish guide is to equip you with the knowledge to make an informed decision that leads to a thriving, beautiful aquatic environment for whichever fish you choose.

Size, Lifespan, and Tank Requirements: A Deep Dive into Arowana Fish vs Goldfish Care

This is arguably the most critical section for any aspiring owner. The sheer difference in physical needs between an arowana and a goldfish dictates almost everything else about their care. Let’s break it down.

Arowana’s Grandeur: Space is Key

When we talk about arowanas, we’re talking about big fish. Really big fish. These magnificent creatures are not for the faint of heart or small apartments. They grow rapidly and require an immense amount of space to thrive.

  • Size: Arowanas can reach lengths of 2 to 3 feet (60-90 cm) or more in a home aquarium, depending on the species. Imagine a fish as long as your arm, or even your leg!
  • Lifespan: With proper care, an arowana can live for 15 to 20 years, sometimes even longer. This is a significant, long-term commitment, akin to getting a large dog or a parrot.
  • Tank Size: This is where many aspiring arowana owners face a reality check. A juvenile arowana might start in a 50-75 gallon tank, but it will quickly outgrow it. An adult arowana absolutely requires a tank of at least 150-250 gallons, with many experts recommending 300+ gallons for optimal health and comfort. We’re talking about tanks that are often custom-built and weigh hundreds, if not thousands, of pounds when full.
  • Filtration: Due to their size and predatory diet, arowanas produce a substantial bio-load. Robust filtration, often involving multiple external filters (canisters or sumps), is non-negotiable. Excellent water quality is paramount for their long-term health.
  • Tank Cover: Arowanas are powerful jumpers. A heavy, securely fitting lid is crucial to prevent them from leaping out of the tank, which is a common and heartbreaking problem.

Understanding how to arowana fish vs goldfish in terms of space is vital. An arowana is an investment in a large-scale aquatic display.

Goldfish Charm: Surprisingly Demanding

Many beginners often think of goldfish as small, easy fish that can live in a bowl. This is a harmful myth! While they don’t reach the colossal size of an arowana, goldfish are far from tiny, and they have specific needs that are often overlooked.

  • Size: Common goldfish varieties (like Comets or Shubunkins) can easily grow to 8-12 inches (20-30 cm) or more. Fancy goldfish (Orandas, Ryukins, Fantails) are generally smaller, often 6-8 inches (15-20 cm), but they are bulkier.
  • Lifespan: When kept in appropriate conditions, goldfish can live for 10-15 years, and even up to 20 years! This longevity is a testament to their hardiness when properly cared for.
  • Tank Size: Forget the bowls! A single common goldfish needs at least 20-30 gallons of water. For fancy goldfish, a good rule of thumb is 20 gallons for the first fish and an additional 10 gallons for each subsequent fish. This space is crucial for their growth and to dilute their significant waste production.
  • Filtration: Goldfish are notorious for producing a lot of waste. A powerful filter (often an HOB or canister filter rated for a larger tank size than you have) is essential to keep the water clean and healthy.
  • Temperature: Goldfish are coldwater fish, ideally kept between 65-75°F (18-24°C). While they can tolerate a wider range, stable temperatures are best.

The benefits of arowana fish vs goldfish might seem skewed towards goldfish for ease, but even goldfish require thoughtful planning for their size and waste output. They offer a different kind of “benefit” in being more accessible in terms of initial tank size, but still demand respect for their needs.

Diet and Feeding Habits: Fueling Your Fin-tastic Friends

What you feed your fish, and how often, plays a massive role in their health, color, and activity levels. Arowanas and goldfish have very different culinary preferences.

The Arowana’s Predatory Appetite

Arowanas are primarily carnivores and active hunters in the wild. Their diet needs to reflect this to keep them healthy and vibrant.

  • Diet: Young arowanas will readily consume insects (crickets, mealworms), small fish (feeder guppies, minnows – though be cautious of disease), and shrimp. As they grow, their diet should consist of high-quality frozen foods like market shrimp, krill, silversides, and even pieces of fish fillet (tilapia, cod). Some specially formulated arowana pellets are available and can supplement their diet, but shouldn’t be the sole food source.
  • Feeding Frequency: Juveniles might be fed once or twice a day, while adult arowanas typically do well with one substantial meal every other day or a few times a week. Overfeeding can lead to health issues and rapid water quality degradation.
  • Enrichment: Offering live food occasionally can provide mental stimulation and allow them to exercise their natural hunting instincts, but ensure the live food is disease-free.

Following these arowana fish vs goldfish best practices for feeding ensures your dragon fish stays healthy and active.

Goldfish: Omnivores with a Hearty Hunger

Goldfish are opportunistic omnivores. They’ll eat almost anything, which makes them susceptible to overfeeding and related health problems.

  • Diet: A high-quality goldfish pellet or flake food should form the bulk of their diet. Supplement this with blanched vegetables like peas (deshelled), spinach, and lettuce. They also enjoy occasional protein treats like bloodworms, brine shrimp, and daphnia (frozen or live).
  • Feeding Frequency: Small amounts, 2-3 times a day. Only feed what they can consume in 2-3 minutes. Goldfish don’t have true stomachs and will constantly beg for food, but resist the urge to overfeed!
  • Fiber: The vegetable component is crucial for their digestion, helping prevent common issues like swim bladder disease.

Considering a sustainable arowana fish vs goldfish approach to feeding means researching where your live/frozen foods come from for arowanas, and ensuring varied, balanced nutrition for goldfish to prevent waste and support long-term health.

Temperament and Tank Mates: Harmony or Hierarchy?

The personality of your fish will greatly influence the type of aquarium you can create. Arowanas and goldfish couldn’t be more different in this regard.

Arowana: The Solitary Monarch

Arowanas are powerful, predatory fish with strong personalities. They are often best kept as single specimens.

  • Aggression: Arowanas can be highly territorial and aggressive, especially towards other arowanas or fish that resemble them. They are known to eat smaller tank mates.
  • Tank Mates: If you absolutely must have tank mates, they need to be carefully chosen. They should be robust, fast-swimming, and large enough not to be considered food. Examples include large plecos, datnoids, large schooling barbs (like Tinfoil Barbs, though these also get huge), or certain large cichlids. This is an advanced technique and often leads to common problems with arowana fish vs goldfish if not executed perfectly.
  • Solitary Nature: Many aquarists find the most success and enjoyment from keeping a single arowana as a majestic centerpiece, allowing it to fully express its natural behaviors without stress from tank mates.

Goldfish: Social and Serene (Mostly)

Goldfish are generally peaceful and social creatures, preferring to live in groups of their own kind.

  • Social Behavior: Goldfish thrive in the company of other goldfish. They interact, swim together, and seem happier when in a shoal.
  • Tank Mates: Compatibility is key. Goldfish are coldwater fish, so tropical tank mates are usually out. Other coldwater species like White Cloud Mountain Minnows or some varieties of loaches can sometimes work, but the best tank mates are other goldfish of similar size and swimming ability. Avoid mixing common, fast-swimming goldfish with slow, fancy varieties, as the faster ones will outcompete the slower ones for food.
  • Predation Risk: While generally peaceful, a very large goldfish might attempt to eat tiny fry or shrimp, but they are not true predators like arowanas.

Considering eco-friendly arowana fish vs goldfish approaches here means thinking about the impact of sourcing appropriate tank mates, especially for species that might be wild-caught. Opting for captive-bred fish whenever possible is always a good practice.

Common Problems and Health Considerations for Arowana Fish vs Goldfish

Every fish can face health challenges, but understanding the common ailments for each species can help you prevent and treat them effectively. This is where your arowana fish vs goldfish care guide truly shines.

Arowana-Specific Challenges

Arowanas are generally hardy, but they are susceptible to a few specific conditions, often related to their environment or diet.

  • Droopy Eye (DE): This is a common and often cosmetic condition where one or both eyes appear to droop downwards. It’s thought to be caused by a high-fat diet, looking down at food on the substrate, or genetics. Prevention involves a lean diet and ensuring food floats or is offered at the surface.
  • Fin Rot and Fungal Infections: Poor water quality, stress, or injuries can lead to fin rot or fungal infections. Maintaining pristine water parameters is the best defense.
  • Hole-in-the-Head (HLLE): While less common in arowanas than some cichlids, poor water quality, nutritional deficiencies, and stress can contribute to this condition, which manifests as pitting or lesions on the head.
  • Jumpers: As mentioned, arowanas are powerful jumpers. An unsecured tank lid is a recipe for disaster.

Many common problems with arowana fish vs goldfish stem from inadequate tank size and poor water management, highlighting the need for vigilance.

Goldfish Health Woes

Goldfish are robust but have their own set of common issues, often linked to diet or water quality.

  • Swim Bladder Disease: This is perhaps the most common goldfish ailment, where the fish struggles to maintain buoyancy. It’s often caused by diet (dry flake food that expands, lack of fiber), constipation, or bacterial infections. Feeding blanched peas and soaking dry food can help prevent it.
  • Ich (White Spot Disease): A parasitic infection that appears as small white spots on the body and fins. It’s usually brought on by stress (poor water quality, temperature fluctuations) or new, infected fish.
  • Fin Rot and Fungal Infections: Similar to arowanas, poor water quality is the leading cause. Regular water changes and a clean environment are crucial.
  • Dropsy: This is a symptom, not a disease itself, where the fish swells and its scales protrude like a pinecone. It’s usually a sign of internal organ failure, often due to bacterial infection or severe stress.

For both species, the foundation of good health is excellent water quality, a balanced diet, and a stress-free environment. This is a core principle in any arowana fish vs goldfish care guide.

The Investment: Cost and Commitment of Your Aquatic Companion

Owning either an arowana or a goldfish is a commitment, but the scale of that commitment differs dramatically.

Arowana: A Significant Financial and Time Commitment

Let’s not sugarcoat it: arowanas are expensive. They are an investment that goes far beyond the initial purchase price of the fish.

  • Fish Cost: Arowana prices vary wildly by species, size, and color. A common Silver Arowana might start around $50-$100 for a juvenile, but rarer species like Asian Arowanas (which are CITES protected and require documentation) can cost hundreds to thousands, or even tens of thousands of dollars.
  • Setup Cost: The tank itself will be a major expense, easily running into hundreds or thousands of dollars for the sizes required. Add to that powerful filtration systems, heaters, lighting, substrate, and decor, and you’re looking at a substantial upfront investment.
  • Running Costs: Large tanks require more electricity for heating and filtration. Feeding a large predator with high-quality frozen foods and live feeders can also add up significantly over the years.
  • Time Commitment: Maintenance for a large tank is time-consuming. Weekly water changes (often 25-50% of hundreds of gallons), filter cleaning, and careful observation of your fish are all part of the routine.

The benefits of arowana fish vs goldfish here are purely aesthetic and prestige-based for the arowana – you’re investing in a living piece of art and a truly awe-inspiring pet.

Goldfish: Accessible Entry, Ongoing Care

Goldfish are generally much more affordable to acquire, but don’t mistake “cheap fish” for “cheap to keep.”

  • Fish Cost: Common goldfish can be a few dollars. Even fancy goldfish are typically in the $10-$50 range, making them very accessible.
  • Setup Cost: A proper 20-30 gallon tank setup for a goldfish (tank, filter, heater if needed, substrate, decor) might cost $100-$300 initially. While less than an arowana, it’s still more than a “bowl and fish” mentality suggests.
  • Running Costs: Goldfish food is relatively inexpensive. Electricity costs for a smaller tank are also lower.
  • Time Commitment: While less demanding than an arowana tank, goldfish still require regular water changes (often 25-50% weekly or bi-weekly depending on tank size and stocking), filter maintenance, and daily feeding. Their long lifespan means this is a commitment for many years.

When considering how to arowana fish vs goldfish in terms of overall cost, the goldfish offers a much lower barrier to entry, but both demand responsible, ongoing financial and time investment.

Making Your Choice: Which Fish is Right for You?

So, after exploring the vast differences, how do you decide? The key is honest self-assessment. There’s no “better” fish, only the better fit for *you*.

Ask yourself these critical questions:

  • Do I have the space? Arowanas need enormous tanks. Goldfish need significantly more than a bowl.
  • What’s my budget? Both initial setup and ongoing costs are vastly different. An arowana is a luxury pet.
  • How much experience do I have? Arowanas are for advanced aquarists who understand complex water chemistry and fish behavior. Goldfish are more forgiving, but still require proper husbandry.
  • What kind of aesthetic am I going for? Do you want a solitary, majestic centerpiece, or a vibrant, interactive community?
  • How much time can I commit? Both are long-lived, requiring years of consistent care.

If you’re dreaming of a truly grand, awe-inspiring display and have the resources, space, and experience, an arowana can be an incredibly rewarding venture. If you’re looking for an interactive, personable, and relatively easier-to-manage pet that still offers a long lifespan and beautiful diversity, goldfish are fantastic companions.

Remember these arowana fish vs goldfish tips: research is your best friend, and always prioritize the well-being of your aquatic friends.

Frequently Asked Questions About Arowana Fish vs Goldfish

Let’s tackle some common queries you might have when considering these two fascinating fish.

Can Arowanas and Goldfish Live Together?

Absolutely not. This is one of the most common misconceptions. Arowanas are large, aggressive predators. Goldfish, even large ones, would be seen as food by an arowana due to their size, slow swimming, and lack of defensive capabilities. Additionally, their temperature and water parameter needs are different. Housing them together would be detrimental, if not fatal, for the goldfish.

Which fish is easier for a beginner?

Goldfish are generally considered easier for beginners, but with a crucial caveat: they still require a proper, adequately sized tank and good filtration. They are hardier and more forgiving of minor mistakes than arowanas. Arowanas are definitely for intermediate to advanced aquarists due to their immense size, specialized diet, and specific water quality demands.

What are the main benefits of choosing an Arowana?

The primary benefits of owning an arowana are their incredible presence and beauty. They are living jewels, captivating to watch, and can become a stunning centerpiece in a large home or office. Their intelligence and unique behaviors also offer a deep connection for dedicated aquarists. Many also appreciate the challenge and prestige associated with successfully keeping such a magnificent creature.

Are there any eco-friendly considerations when buying an Arowana?

Yes, absolutely. Many arowana species, particularly Asian Arowanas, are listed under CITES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora) due to overcollection in the wild. If considering an Asian Arowana, ensure it comes with CITES documentation, indicating it is captive-bred and legally traded. For other species, try to find reputable breeders or suppliers who source fish sustainably, avoiding wild-caught specimens when possible. This contributes to sustainable arowana fish vs goldfish practices within the hobby.

Can Goldfish really live for over a decade?

Yes! It’s a testament to how often goldfish are misunderstood. The common image of a goldfish living only a few months in a small bowl is due to improper care. In a spacious, well-filtered tank with appropriate food and regular maintenance, many goldfish varieties can easily live for 10-15 years, with some even reaching 20 years or more. They are hardy fish when given the right environment.

Conclusion: Your Aquatic Journey Awaits!

There you have it! A deep dive into the fascinating, yet fundamentally different, worlds of the arowana fish vs goldfish. Both offer unique joys and challenges to the dedicated aquarist, but it’s clear they require very different commitments of space, time, and resources.

Whether you’re drawn to the ancient majesty of the arowana or the charming resilience of the goldfish, remember that responsible pet ownership begins with thorough research and a commitment to providing the best possible environment. Your chosen aquatic companion will reward you with years of beauty and wonder.

So, take this guide, assess your capabilities, and choose wisely. Your next aquatic masterpiece is waiting! Go forth and create a thriving, beautiful aquarium!

Howard Parker
Latest posts by Howard Parker (see all)