Arowana Fish And Goldfish – Decoding Compatibility For A Thriving

Written ByHoward Parker

Hey there, fellow aquarist! Have you ever found yourself gazing at your beautiful tank, dreaming up exciting new additions or unique pairings? It’s a common thought, especially when you see two such iconic fish as the majestic arowana and the charming goldfish. The idea of housing arowana fish and goldfish together might spark curiosity, perhaps you’ve seen a picture or heard a whisper in a forum.

Well, you’ve landed in the perfect spot! At Aquifarm, we’re all about helping you create and maintain truly stunning, healthy aquariums. Today, we’re going to dive deep into the fascinating world of both the arowana and the goldfish, and more importantly, address the burning question: can these two distinct species coexist peacefully? We promise to give you the real, expert lowdown on how to arowana fish and goldfish considerations play out in a real-world aquarium.

This comprehensive arowana fish and goldfish guide will cut through the noise, clarify common misconceptions, and arm you with the knowledge for truly successful, sustainable fishkeeping. We’ll explore their natural habitats, dietary needs, temperament, and crucial tank requirements, so you can make informed decisions and avoid common problems. By the end, you’ll understand the best practices for both species, ensuring a happy, healthy life for your finned friends.

The Allure and the Reality: Why “Arowana Fish and Goldfish” is a Common Query

It’s easy to see why the idea of keeping arowana fish and goldfish together captures the imagination. Arowanas are often called “dragon fish” for their shimmering scales and powerful, ancient appearance, while goldfish are beloved for their playful antics and vibrant colors. Visually, the contrast might seem appealing, and the sheer availability of goldfish often leads new arowana owners to wonder if they make suitable companions or even feeder fish.

However, as an experienced aquarist, I need to tell you upfront: while the thought is intriguing, the reality of successfully keeping arowana fish and goldfish together long-term in a harmonious, healthy environment is virtually non-existent. There are fundamental differences in their biology, behavior, and environmental needs that make this pairing highly problematic. Our goal here isn’t to discourage your enthusiasm, but to empower you with the knowledge to make truly responsible and fulfilling choices for your aquatic pets.

Unpacking the Needs of an Arowana: A Majestic Predator

Let’s start by understanding the arowana, a truly magnificent freshwater fish found primarily in South America, Southeast Asia, and Australia, depending on the species. These are not your average aquarium residents; they are apex predators with very specific demands. When we talk about arowana fish and goldfish tips, understanding the arowana’s core nature is paramount.

Arowana Habitat and Size Requirements: Go Big or Go Home

Arowanas are built for vast spaces. They are powerful, active swimmers that grow incredibly large. Silver Arowanas (Osteoglossum bicirrhosum), a common species in the hobby, can easily reach lengths of 3-4 feet (90-120 cm) in captivity. Asian Arowanas (Scleropages formosus) can reach similar sizes. This means they require an enormous aquarium.

  • Tank Size: For a single adult arowana, a tank of at least 250 gallons (950 liters) is the absolute minimum, with 300+ gallons (1135+ liters) being far more ideal. The tank needs to be wide and long, not just tall, to accommodate their swimming patterns and turning radius.
  • Water Parameters: Arowanas thrive in tropical, warm waters.
    • Temperature: 75-82°F (24-28°C)
    • pH: 6.0-7.5 (slightly acidic to neutral)
    • Hardness: Soft to medium (GH 2-8, KH 3-8)
  • Filtration: Due to their size and messy eating habits, powerful, multi-stage filtration (mechanical, biological, chemical) is non-negotiable. Over-filtration is always better than under-filtration.
  • Tank Cover: Arowanas are notorious jumpers! A heavy, secure lid is essential to prevent them from leaping out of the tank.

Arowana Diet and Predatory Nature: The Ultimate Carnivore

Arowanas are obligate carnivores. In the wild, their diet consists mainly of insects, small fish, crustaceans, and even small birds or bats that fall onto the water’s surface. This predatory instinct is hardwired and cannot be suppressed. Understanding this is key when considering how to arowana fish and goldfish might interact.

  • Primary Diet: High-quality, specially formulated arowana pellets or sticks should form the staple.
  • Supplements: Supplement with a variety of meaty foods like:
    • Frozen silversides, krill, and shrimp
    • Earthworms
    • Large insects (crickets, mealworms)
    • Occasionally, feeder fish (though this comes with risks of disease and nutritional imbalance if not carefully sourced and quarantined).
  • Feeding Frequency: Younger arowanas need to be fed daily, while adults can be fed every other day or a few times a week.

Arowana Temperament and Tank Mates: Solitary and Aggressive

Arowanas are generally solitary fish and can be highly territorial and aggressive, especially towards other arowanas or fish of similar shape and size. Anything that fits into their surprisingly large mouth is considered a potential meal. This is a crucial piece of the puzzle when evaluating arowana fish and goldfish best practices.

  • Aggression: They can be very aggressive towards tank mates, particularly if the tank is not large enough or if the other fish are too small.
  • Predation: Any fish small enough to be swallowed will be eaten.
  • Suitable Tank Mates (with caution and adequate space): Other large, semi-aggressive fish that are too big to be eaten and can hold their own. Examples include large datnoids, plecos (like common plecos or sailfin plecos), large cichlids (e.g., oscars, though even these can sometimes be a target), and large silver dollars.

Unpacking the Needs of a Goldfish: A Hardy, Messy Omnivore

Now, let’s turn our attention to the beloved goldfish. Often mistakenly thought of as small, easy “starter fish,” goldfish are actually robust, long-lived creatures that can grow surprisingly large and require specific care. Dispelling myths about goldfish is as important as understanding arowanas when discussing arowana fish and goldfish dynamics.

Goldfish Habitat and Size Requirements: More Than Just a Bowl

Goldfish, especially common and comet varieties, are not meant for bowls! They are coldwater fish that produce a significant bio-load, meaning they create a lot of waste. They can live for 10-20 years or more with proper care.

  • Tank Size: A single common or comet goldfish needs at least 20 gallons (75 liters), with an additional 10 gallons (38 liters) for each subsequent fish. Fancy goldfish varieties (like Orandas or Ryukins) can do well in slightly smaller tanks (10-20 gallons per fish), but still need ample space.
  • Water Parameters: Goldfish prefer cooler, more alkaline water than tropical fish.
    • Temperature: 65-75°F (18-24°C). They can tolerate cooler, but not tropical, temperatures.
    • pH: 7.0-8.0 (neutral to slightly alkaline)
    • Hardness: Medium to hard (GH 8-12, KH 5-10)
  • Filtration: Due to their high waste production, excellent filtration is crucial. Canister filters or large hang-on-back filters with strong biological media are highly recommended. Frequent water changes are also a must.

Goldfish Diet and Growth: The Versatile Grazer

Goldfish are omnivores with a diet consisting of both plant and animal matter. They are opportunistic feeders and will graze constantly if food is available.

  • Primary Diet: High-quality goldfish flakes or pellets specifically designed for goldfish.
  • Supplements: Offer a varied diet with:
    • Blanched vegetables (peas, spinach, zucchini)
    • Brine shrimp (live or frozen)
    • Bloodworms (live or frozen)
    • Daphnia
  • Feeding Frequency: Small amounts 2-3 times a day. Be careful not to overfeed, as this contributes to poor water quality.

Goldfish Temperament and Tank Mates: Peaceful and Slow

Goldfish are generally peaceful and social fish that do best in groups of their own kind. They are relatively slow-moving compared to many tropical species and lack any defensive capabilities against larger, more aggressive fish.

  • Temperament: Docile, curious, and can be quite interactive with their owners.
  • Tank Mates: Best kept with other goldfish. If other species are considered, they must be coldwater, peaceful, and not small enough to be mistaken for food by even a large goldfish. Examples include White Cloud Mountain Minnows (in large, cool tanks) or certain types of snails.

The Incompatible Truth: Common Problems with Arowana Fish and Goldfish Together

Now that we’ve laid out the individual needs of both species, the reasons why keeping arowana fish and goldfish together is a recipe for disaster become glaringly obvious. This is where many aquarists encounter common problems with arowana fish and goldfish pairings.

Water Parameter Discrepancies: A Fundamental Clash

This is arguably the most significant, non-negotiable issue. Arowanas need warm, slightly acidic to neutral water, while goldfish require cooler, neutral to slightly alkaline water. Trying to compromise on these parameters will stress both fish, leading to weakened immune systems, disease, and a shortened lifespan for both.

  • Temperature Shock: An arowana in cold water will become sluggish and prone to illness. A goldfish in warm water will have an accelerated metabolism, leading to stress, oxygen deprivation, and potentially death.
  • pH Imbalance: Significant differences in ideal pH levels can cause osmotic stress, damaging gills and other vital organs.

Predation Risk: A Goldfish is a Meal, Not a Mate

Let’s be blunt: an arowana will view a goldfish as food. It’s not a matter of “if,” but “when.” Arowanas are powerful predators with large mouths. Even a large goldfish is no match for a full-grown arowana. This is the harsh reality that every aspiring aquarist must understand.

  • Instinct: The arowana’s predatory instinct is ingrained. It will hunt and consume any fish small enough to fit into its mouth.
  • Stress for Goldfish: Even if a goldfish isn’t immediately eaten, the constant presence of a predator will cause immense stress, leading to a compromised immune system and susceptibility to disease.

Dietary Conflicts: Different Nutritional Needs

Arowanas are carnivores requiring high-protein, meaty diets. Goldfish are omnivores needing a balanced diet of plant and animal matter. Trying to feed both in the same tank means one or both will not receive adequate nutrition.

  • Arowana Malnutrition: If the arowana is forced to eat goldfish food, it will suffer from nutritional deficiencies.
  • Goldfish Health Issues: If the goldfish eats too much high-protein arowana food, it can lead to digestive issues and swim bladder problems.

Stress and Disease: A Vicious Cycle

The combination of incompatible water parameters, constant stress from predation, and improper diets creates a breeding ground for disease. Goldfish, already messy, will further degrade water quality if stressed, exacerbating the problem for both species.

  • Weakened Immunity: Chronic stress makes fish highly vulnerable to common diseases like ich, fin rot, and bacterial infections.
  • Water Quality Decline: Stressed fish, especially goldfish, can produce more slime coat, which further fouls the water.

Responsible Aquascaping: Sustainable Arowana Fish and Goldfish Keeping (Separately!)

The true path to a beautiful and thriving aquarium, especially when dealing with magnificent fish like arowanas and goldfish, lies in understanding and respecting their individual needs. This is the essence of sustainable arowana fish and goldfish keeping: providing each species with an environment where they can truly flourish. This means, unequivocally, keeping them in separate, species-appropriate tanks.

Ideal Tank Mates for Arowanas: The Gentle Giants

While arowanas are best kept alone, if you have an exceptionally large tank (500+ gallons) and are experienced, you might consider certain tank mates that are too large to be eaten and can tolerate the arowana’s temperament.

  • Large Catfish: Large armored catfish like Plecos (e.g., Common, Sailfin, or Royal Plecos – ensure they are too big to be swallowed) or synodontis catfish can sometimes work.
  • Large Cyprinids: Certain very large, robust cyprinids like Silver Dollars (in a large school) can be fast enough to evade the arowana and large enough not to be an immediate meal.
  • Other Large, Semi-Aggressive Fish: Datnoids, large Knife Fish (e.g., Clown Knife Fish), or even certain large cichlids (like Oscars, though caution is still advised as arowanas can be unpredictable).

Remember, always introduce potential tank mates with extreme caution, ensure ample space, and have a backup plan (another tank) if aggression becomes an issue. This is crucial for arowana fish and goldfish best practices – applying the same diligence to all tank mate decisions.

Ideal Tank Mates for Goldfish: The Peaceful Community

Goldfish are happiest and healthiest when kept with other goldfish. They are social creatures and thrive in groups. If you wish to add other species, they must meet the strict criteria of being coldwater, peaceful, and not small enough to be bullied or eaten by a large goldfish.

  • Other Goldfish: This is the ideal pairing. Keep fancy goldfish with other fancy goldfish, and common/comet goldfish with their own kind, as their swimming abilities differ.
  • White Cloud Mountain Minnows: These small, peaceful fish can tolerate similar coldwater temperatures, but ensure the tank is large enough for the goldfish not to see them as snacks.
  • Snails: Larger snails like Mystery Snails or Nerite Snails can be good tank cleaners and are generally safe with goldfish.

Setting Up Optimal Environments: Your Arowana Fish and Goldfish Care Guide

Providing a species-specific environment is the most responsible and rewarding way to care for these magnificent creatures. This is your ultimate arowana fish and goldfish care guide, emphasizing separate, tailored habitats.

For Your Arowana:

  • Tank Size: Minimum 250-300 gallons for one adult. Larger is always better.
  • Decor: Provide open swimming space. Use smooth rocks, large pieces of driftwood, and robust, well-rooted live or artificial plants. Ensure nothing has sharp edges that could injure their delicate scales.
  • Lighting: Moderate lighting. Arowanas appreciate a somewhat dim environment.
  • Water Quality: Strict maintenance schedule. Weekly 25-30% water changes are essential. Test water parameters regularly (ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, pH, temperature).
  • Diet: High-quality arowana pellets supplemented with varied meaty foods.

For Your Goldfish:

  • Tank Size: Minimum 20 gallons per common goldfish, 10-20 gallons per fancy goldfish.
  • Decor: Smooth gravel or sand substrate. Decorate with smooth rocks, driftwood, and live plants (like Anubias, Java Fern, or Hornwort) that can withstand their grazing. Avoid sharp objects.
  • Lighting: Standard aquarium lighting is fine.
  • Water Quality: Goldfish are heavy waste producers. Weekly 25-50% water changes are critical. Maintain excellent filtration. Monitor parameters closely.
  • Diet: High-quality goldfish pellets/flakes supplemented with blanched vegetables and occasional protein treats.

Remember, while arowanas are not beginner fish due to their specialized needs and immense size, understanding their care, just like the relatively easier (but still demanding) care of goldfish, is the first step towards becoming a truly knowledgeable aquarist. Don’t worry—with the right information and dedication, you can absolutely master the care of these incredible creatures (each in their own suitable environment)!

Frequently Asked Questions About Arowana Fish and Goldfish

Let’s address some of the most common questions that pop up about arowana fish and goldfish, ensuring you have all the facts.

Can arowanas and goldfish ever live together?

No, not safely or ethically for the long term. Their fundamental differences in size, diet, water parameter requirements, and temperament make cohabitation impossible without causing severe stress, disease, or predation. An arowana will inevitably eat any goldfish it can fit in its mouth, and the differing water needs will harm both species.

What are the biggest risks of keeping them together?

The primary risks are predation (the arowana eating the goldfish), severe stress for both fish due to incompatible water parameters (temperature, pH), and differing dietary needs leading to malnutrition or digestive issues. This combination significantly increases the likelihood of disease and premature death for both species.

What are good feeder fish alternatives for arowanas?

Instead of goldfish, which carry high risks of disease and nutritional deficiencies, consider healthier alternatives for your arowana. High-quality arowana pellets or sticks should be the staple. Supplement with frozen silversides, krill, earthworms, large crickets, or ghost shrimp. If live fish are a must, strictly quarantined, parasite-free options like guppies or small minnows from a reliable source are sometimes used, but it’s generally best to stick to non-fish options to avoid introducing pathogens.

How can I ensure the best care for my arowana or goldfish?

The best care involves providing a species-specific environment. For an arowana, this means a very large, dedicated tank (250+ gallons) with warm, slightly acidic water, powerful filtration, and a high-protein diet. For goldfish, it means a spacious tank (20+ gallons per common goldfish) with cooler, neutral to alkaline water, robust filtration, and a varied omnivorous diet. Research each species thoroughly, commit to regular water changes, and monitor water parameters diligently.

Conclusion

So, there you have it, fellow fish enthusiast. While the thought of pairing arowana fish and goldfish might initially seem appealing, the reality is that these two magnificent species have vastly different needs that make cohabitation detrimental to both. Our journey through their individual requirements has shown us why trying to force them together leads to inevitable problems, not a beautiful, harmonious tank.

The true joy of aquarium keeping, and the hallmark of an expert aquarist, lies in creating environments where each fish can truly thrive according to its natural instincts and biological needs. By understanding the distinct demands of your arowana and your goldfish, and providing them with their own tailored, spacious, and appropriate habitats, you’re not just keeping fish – you’re fostering vibrant, healthy ecosystems.

Embrace the challenge of responsible fishkeeping, and you’ll be rewarded with the unparalleled beauty and fascinating behaviors of truly happy, healthy aquatic companions. Keep researching, keep learning, and most importantly, keep nurturing your passion for these incredible creatures. Go forth and create truly thriving aquariums!

Howard Parker
Latest posts by Howard Parker (see all)