Amano Shrimp Vs Caridina Shrimp – Your Ultimate Guide To Care, Water

Written ByHoward Parker

So, you’re ready to add a dedicated clean-up crew to your aquarium, and you’ve narrowed it down to shrimp. That’s a fantastic choice! But now you face the classic aquarist’s dilemma: choosing between the tireless, algae-devouring Amano shrimp and the dazzlingly beautiful Caridina shrimp.

It’s a common crossroads, and it’s easy to feel a bit lost. You see stunning pictures of vibrant red and white Crystal Shrimp, but you hear stories about how hardy and effective Amanos are. Which one is right for your tank?

Don’t worry—you’ve come to the right place. In this complete amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp guide, we’re going to break down everything you need to know. We’ll compare their care needs, water parameters, diet, breeding, and temperament so you can make a confident, informed decision for your underwater world.

By the end of this article, you’ll know exactly which of these fascinating invertebrates is the perfect fit for your setup and your goals as a hobbyist.

Meet the Contenders: A Quick Introduction

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty details, let’s get properly acquainted with our two shrimp superstars. While they might look similar at a glance, they come from very different backgrounds and play different roles in an aquarium.

The Amano Shrimp (Caridina multidentata): The Algae-Eating Powerhouse

Often called the “Algae-Eating Shrimp,” the Amano gets its name from the legendary aquascaper Takashi Amano, who popularized their use for controlling algae in nature aquariums. These shrimp are the undisputed champions of tank cleaning.

They are larger than most dwarf shrimp, with a translucent, grayish body covered in a distinctive pattern of dots and dashes. They are workhorses, known for their relentless appetite for nearly all types of algae, including stubborn Black Beard Algae and hair algae.

The Caridina Shrimp Family: The Dazzling Jewels

When people talk about “Caridina shrimp,” they’re usually referring to a whole group of stunningly colorful species. The most famous are the Crystal Red Shrimp (CRS) and Crystal Black Shrimp (CBS), but this family also includes Taiwan Bees, Blue Bolts, and many more.

These shrimp are the supermodels of the invertebrate world. They are smaller and more delicate than Amanos, and their primary role is ornamental. Hobbyists keep them for their breathtaking beauty and the rewarding challenge of breeding them to create new color patterns.

The Great Debate: Amano Shrimp vs Caridina Shrimp at a Glance

To give you a quick overview, here’s a simple breakdown of the key differences. This is the core of our amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp comparison.

  • Difficulty: Amano shrimp are very easy and perfect for beginners. Caridina shrimp range from moderate to difficult, requiring much more attention to detail.
  • Water Parameters: Amanos are highly adaptable and thrive in a wide range of conditions, often doing well in treated tap water. Caridinas are specialists that demand very specific soft, acidic water, which usually requires using RO/DI water.
  • Primary Role: Amanos are functional, serving as an elite algae-control crew. Caridinas are primarily ornamental, kept for their beauty and breeding potential.
  • Size: Amanos are the larger of the two, reaching up to 2 inches (5 cm). Caridinas are true dwarf shrimp, typically maxing out around 1.25 inches (3 cm).
  • Breeding: Breeding Amanos in an aquarium is extremely difficult as their larvae require brackish water to develop. Caridinas breed entirely in freshwater, making it a challenging but achievable goal for dedicated hobbyists.
  • Cost: Amano shrimp are generally inexpensive. High-grade Caridina shrimp can be quite expensive, sometimes fetching high prices for rare patterns.

Diving Deep: Water Parameter Requirements

This is, without a doubt, the most critical difference between these two shrimp. Getting the water right is the foundation of success, and this is where their paths dramatically diverge. This is the most important part of any amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp care guide.

Amano Shrimp: The Forgiving Friend

One of the biggest benefits of amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp is their incredible hardiness. They aren’t fussy and can adapt to the water conditions found in most established community tanks.

Here are their ideal, but flexible, parameters:

  • Temperature: 70-80°F (21-27°C)
  • pH: 6.5 – 8.0
  • GH (General Hardness): 6 – 15 dGH
  • KH (Carbonate Hardness): 2 – 8 dKH

For most people, properly dechlorinated tap water falls within these ranges, making Amano shrimp incredibly accessible. Just be sure to acclimate them slowly to your tank, and they’ll be happy campers.

Caridina Shrimp: The Sensitive Specialist

This is where things get serious. Caridina shrimp, like Crystal Reds, are not adaptable. They evolved in soft, acidic streams and require you to replicate those conditions precisely. Stability is key—sudden swings in parameters can be fatal.

Typical parameters for Crystal Red Shrimp are:

  • Temperature: 68-74°F (20-23°C) – note the cooler preference!
  • pH: 5.8 – 6.8
  • GH (General Hardness): 4 – 6 dGH
  • KH (Carbonate Hardness): 0 – 1 dKH

Achieving these numbers is nearly impossible with standard tap water. Serious Caridina keepers almost exclusively use reverse osmosis deionized (RO/DI) water and then add back specific minerals using a product like Salty Shrimp Bee Mineral GH+ to hit the exact GH target. They also use an active, buffering substrate (like ADA Amazonia or Fluval Stratum) to help lock the pH in the desired acidic range.

Diet and Feeding: What’s on the Menu?

While both are scavengers, their dietary needs and feeding behaviors highlight their different roles in the aquarium.

Amano Shrimp: The Unfussy Janitor

Amanos are eating machines. Their primary diet in your tank will be biofilm and, most importantly, algae. They will graze constantly, tackling everything from soft green algae on glass to pesky hair algae tangled in your plants.

They are also opportunistic and will happily devour leftover fish flakes, sinking pellets, algae wafers, and blanched vegetables like zucchini or spinach. A pro tip: if you want them to focus on algae, don’t overfeed them with supplemental foods! A hungry Amano is an effective Amano.

Caridina Shrimp: The Delicate Grazer

Caridina shrimp are much more delicate feeders. Their main food source is biofilm—the invisible layer of microorganisms that grows on all surfaces in a mature aquarium. They graze on this constantly.

Their diet should be supplemented with high-quality, specialized shrimp foods that provide a complete range of nutrients without fouling the water. Adding botanicals like Indian Almond Leaves (Catappa leaves) is one of the best practices for Caridina keepers. The leaves provide a continuous source of food as they break down and release beneficial tannins into the water.

Breeding in the Home Aquarium: A Tale of Two Strategies

For many hobbyists, the prospect of breeding their aquatic pets is a major draw. When it comes to how to amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp breeding, the experiences couldn’t be more different.

The Amano Shrimp’s Impossible Journey

You will see female Amano shrimp carrying eggs (becoming “berried”), but you won’t see baby shrimp in your freshwater tank. This is because Amano shrimp have a complex breeding cycle.

The females release larvae, not miniature shrimp. These larvae must drift downstream into brackish or full saltwater to develop before migrating back to freshwater. Replicating this in a home aquarium is incredibly difficult and not a realistic goal for 99% of hobbyists. This is why most Amano shrimp are wild-caught, a key point to consider when thinking about sustainable amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp options.

Breeding Caridina Shrimp: The Rewarding Challenge

Here’s where Caridinas shine for dedicated enthusiasts. They breed entirely in freshwater. A berried female will carry her eggs for about 30 days before hatching fully formed, miniature versions of the adults.

Successfully breeding Caridina shrimp is a badge of honor in the hobby. It’s proof that you have mastered their sensitive water requirements and created a stable, thriving environment. Because they are almost exclusively captive-bred, they represent a more eco-friendly amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp choice for those concerned with sustainability.

Behavior and Tank Mates: Who Plays Well with Others?

A shrimp’s temperament can affect the entire dynamic of your tank. Amanos are bold and boisterous, while Caridinas are shy and gentle.

Amano Shrimp: Bold, Active, and a Little Greedy

Amanos are confident and always busy. You’ll see them all over the tank, actively exploring and cleaning. They are also notoriously food-aggressive. It’s common to see an Amano swim off with an entire algae wafer, protecting its prize from fish and other shrimp. This boldness makes them suitable for most peaceful community tanks, as long as the fish are not large enough to eat them (avoid cichlids, large gouramis, and angelfish).

Caridina Shrimp: Shy, Peaceful, and Delicate

Caridina shrimp are much more reclusive. They feel safest in a heavily planted tank with lots of hiding spots. They are best kept in a species-only tank to truly appreciate their behavior and encourage breeding. If you must have tank mates, choose only the most peaceful and tiny companions, like Otocinclus catfish or other dwarf shrimp. Even a moderately active fish can stress them into hiding permanently or outcompete them for food.

The Final Verdict: Which Shrimp is Right for Your Tank?

We’ve covered a lot of ground. Now it’s time to make a decision. This final section of our amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp guide will help you choose with confidence.

You should choose Amano Shrimp if:

  • You are a beginner looking for a hardy, forgiving invertebrate.
  • Your number one goal is powerful and effective algae control.
  • You have a standard community aquarium and plan to use treated tap water.
  • You are not interested in the challenges of breeding shrimp.

You should choose Caridina Shrimp if:

  • You are an intermediate or advanced hobbyist looking for a new challenge.
  • You are captivated by their stunning colors and want a “showpiece” invertebrate.
  • You are willing and able to invest in RO/DI water, remineralizing salts, and specialized substrate.
  • The idea of breeding and raising delicate shrimp excites you.

Frequently Asked Questions About Amano Shrimp vs Caridina Shrimp

Can I keep Amano and Caridina shrimp together?

It’s generally not recommended. Their water parameter needs are polar opposites. Amanos thrive in the harder, more alkaline water that would be harmful to Caridinas, while Caridinas need the soft, acidic water that Amanos would not prefer. It’s best to choose one and build your tank around their specific needs.

Which shrimp is better for a planted tank?

Both are excellent, but for different reasons! Amanos are the superior janitors and are invaluable for controlling algae outbreaks, especially in high-tech tanks with strong lighting and CO2. Caridinas add a stunning pop of color against green plants and are safe for even the most delicate mosses, but they won’t clean as aggressively.

Why are my Caridina shrimp dying but my Amanos are fine?

This is one of the most common problems with amano shrimp vs caridina shrimp cohabitation and almost always points to water parameters. Your water is likely too hard (high GH/KH) or the pH is too high for the sensitive Caridinas. The hardy Amanos can tolerate these conditions easily, but they are outside the narrow range Caridinas need to survive, let alone thrive.

How many shrimp should I start with?

For Amano shrimp, a group of 3-5 is a great start for a 10-20 gallon tank to make a dent in algae. For Caridina shrimp, it’s best to start with a colony of at least 10. A larger group helps them feel more secure, encouraging them to be more active and promoting successful breeding.

Your Underwater World Awaits

Choosing between Amano and Caridina shrimp isn’t about picking a “better” shrimp, but rather the “right” shrimp for you and your aquarium. The Amano is a dependable, hardworking janitor perfect for almost any community tank. The Caridina is a beautiful, delicate specialist that offers a deeply rewarding experience for the dedicated aquarist.

By understanding their unique needs, you’ve already taken the most important step toward success. Whichever path you choose, you’re about to add a fascinating and dynamic new element to your aquatic hobby.

Happy shrimping!

Howard Parker
Latest posts by Howard Parker (see all)
Related posts
  • Amano Shrimp Died After Molting – Your Guide To Preventing Future
  • Amano Shrimp On Top Of Each Other – Decoding Their Piling Behavior