Amano Shrimp Or Ghost Shrimp – Your Definitive Guide To Choosing

Written ByHoward Parker

Let’s be honest. You’re staring at your beautiful aquarium, but that pesky film of algae on the glass or that patch of hair algae on your driftwood is driving you crazy. You’ve heard about the legendary “cleanup crews,” and two names keep popping up: the Amano shrimp and the Ghost shrimp. But which one is right for you?

I get it. Choosing the right inhabitants for your tank can feel overwhelming. You want a creature that will help keep things tidy without causing chaos for your fish. You’ve come to the right place. Think of me as your friendly guide in the world of freshwater invertebrates.

I promise that by the end of this article, you’ll have a crystal-clear understanding of the differences between these two popular shrimp. We’ll dive deep into their algae-eating abilities, care needs, personalities, and potential pitfalls. This is your complete amano shrimp or ghost shrimp guide to help you confidently pick the perfect tiny janitor for your aquatic world.

Meet the Contenders: Amano Shrimp vs. Ghost Shrimp at a Glance

Before we get into the nitty-gritty, let’s start with a quick side-by-side comparison. Sometimes seeing the key differences laid out simply is the best way to begin.

  • Scientific Name:
    • Amano Shrimp: Caridina multidentata
    • Ghost Shrimp: Palaemonetes paludosus (and related species)
  • Size:
    • Amano Shrimp: Up to 2 inches (often larger and bulkier)
    • Ghost Shrimp: Up to 1.5 inches (more delicate and slender)
  • Lifespan:
    • Amano Shrimp: 2-3+ years
    • Ghost Shrimp: Around 1 year
  • Cost:
    • Amano Shrimp: Moderate ($3-$6 per shrimp)
    • Ghost Shrimp: Very Inexpensive ($0.30-$1 per shrimp, often sold as feeders)
  • Primary Role:
    • Amano Shrimp: Specialist Algae Eater
    • Ghost Shrimp: Generalist Scavenger
  • Temperament:
    • Amano Shrimp: Peaceful and industrious
    • Ghost Shrimp: Mostly peaceful, but can be nippy at feeding time

The Algae-Eating Champion: Which Shrimp Cleans Best?

This is the main event for many aquarists! The primary reason you’re likely considering shrimp is for algae control. Here, there’s a clear winner, but that doesn’t mean the other is useless. Understanding the benefits of amano shrimp or ghost shrimp starts with their appetite.

The Amano Shrimp: A Voracious Algae Annihilator

If you have a genuine algae problem—especially soft green algae, brown diatom algae, or the dreaded hair algae—the Amano shrimp is your champion. They are relentless workers. Named after the legendary aquascaper Takashi Amano, who popularized their use, these shrimp will graze all day long.

They methodically clean plant leaves, driftwood, and substrate. A small team of Amanos can make a visible difference in an algae-ridden tank within a week. They are the special forces of algae cleanup.

The Ghost Shrimp: A Generalist Scavenger

Ghost shrimp, on the other hand, are more like opportunistic janitors. They will certainly nibble on some soft algae and biofilm, but it’s not their primary focus. Their real talent lies in scavenging.

They excel at finding and devouring leftover fish food that has fallen to the bottom, decaying plant matter, and other detritus. By doing this, they help prevent the buildup of waste that can lead to algae blooms. So, think of them as more of a preventative measure than an active solution to an existing algae problem.

Amano Shrimp or Ghost Shrimp: A Deep Dive into Care and Tank Mates

So, you’ve seen what they eat, but how do you keep them happy and healthy? This detailed amano shrimp or ghost shrimp care guide will walk you through everything you need to know. Don’t worry—both are quite hardy and great for beginners!

Amano Shrimp Care Guide

Amanos are robust, but they do have a few specific needs. Getting their environment right is key to enjoying these algae-eaters for years to come.

  • Tank Size: A minimum of 10 gallons is recommended. They are active and appreciate having space to roam and forage.
  • Water Parameters: They prefer a stable environment. Aim for a pH of 6.5-7.5, temperatures between 70-78°F (21-26°C), and soft to moderately hard water. Consistency is more important than hitting an exact number.
  • Diet: While they are famous algae eaters, they cannot survive on algae alone. Supplement their diet with high-quality shrimp pellets, blanched vegetables like zucchini or spinach, and algae wafers to ensure they get all their nutrients.
  • Tank Mates: They are completely peaceful and do well with other peaceful community fish like tetras, rasboras, corydoras, and otocinclus. Avoid any fish large enough to see them as a snack, such as cichlids, large gouramis, or most bettas (some bettas are fine, others are shrimp murderers—it depends on the fish’s personality).
  • Pro Tip: Amano shrimp are notorious escape artists! They can and will climb airline tubing or filter outlets and jump out of the tank. A tight-fitting lid is non-negotiable if you want to keep them safe.

Ghost Shrimp Care Guide

Ghost shrimp are incredibly hardy, which is one reason they are so popular and inexpensive. They are an excellent choice for first-time shrimp keepers.

  • Tank Size: You can keep a small group in a tank as small as 5 gallons, making them perfect for nano setups.
  • Water Parameters: These shrimp are highly adaptable. They can thrive in a wide range of conditions, from a pH of 6.5-8.0 and temperatures of 65-82°F (18-28°C). They are less sensitive to fluctuations than many other shrimp species.
  • Diet: They are true omnivores and will eat almost anything. Leftover fish flakes, shrimp pellets, decaying plant matter—you name it. They are very low-maintenance feeders.
  • Tank Mates: Like Amanos, they are best kept with small, peaceful fish. However, be aware that some Ghost shrimp can be a bit more assertive than Amanos during feeding time, sometimes snatching food from slow-moving bottom dwellers.
  • Important Note: The term “Ghost Shrimp” can be a catch-all for several different species. Occasionally, a more aggressive species like the “Whisker Shrimp” is mislabeled and sold as a Ghost Shrimp. If your shrimp has noticeably long arms and a more aggressive nature, you may have a Whisker Shrimp, which can prey on small fish or other shrimp. Always buy from a reputable source!

Appearance and Identification: Telling Them Apart

At a glance, a beginner might mistake one for the other. They’re both small, mostly clear shrimp. But once you know what to look for, telling them apart is easy. This is a crucial part of our how to amano shrimp or ghost shrimp comparison.

Identifying the Amano Shrimp (Caridina multidentata)

The Amano shrimp has a distinct look. It has a larger, more robust, and almost “hunched” body compared to the slender Ghost shrimp. Their bodies are semi-transparent with a greyish or brownish tint.

The dead giveaway is the pattern on their sides. Amanos have a line of perfect, solid dots running along their lower body and a series of broken dashes or lines along their upper body. This pattern is unmistakable once you see it.

Identifying the Ghost Shrimp (Palaemonetes paludosus)

Ghost shrimp live up to their name: they are almost completely transparent. You can often see their internal organs and the food they’ve just eaten! Their body shape is much straighter and more delicate than an Amano’s.

A key identifying feature is a small, bright orange band on each of their two antennae and sometimes on their tail. They lack the distinct dots and dashes seen on Amano shrimp.

Common Problems with Amano Shrimp or Ghost Shrimp (And How to Solve Them!)

Even with the best care, you might run into a few issues. Don’t panic! Here are some common problems with amano shrimp or ghost shrimp and straightforward solutions.

The Great Escape: Why Your Amano Shrimp Disappeared

As mentioned, Amanos are climbers. If one goes missing, the first place to check is the floor around your tank. The solution is simple: get a lid that covers every opening, or lower your water level by a couple of inches.

Molting Mishaps and the “White Ring of Death”

All shrimp must molt (shed their exoskeleton) to grow. You’ll find their empty shells in the tank—this is a good sign! However, sometimes a molt can fail. A “white ring of death” is a visible split in the shell where the shrimp gets stuck.

This is often caused by incorrect water parameters, specifically GH (General Hardness) and KH (Carbonate Hardness), or a lack of iodine. Ensure your water parameters are stable and consider feeding a specialized shrimp food that contains the minerals they need for healthy molting.

Mysterious Deaths and Acclimation Woes

The single biggest mistake new shrimp keepers make is improper acclimation. Shrimp are highly sensitive to sudden changes in water parameters. Never just plop them into your tank. Use the drip acclimation method over at least an hour to slowly introduce them to your tank’s water. This drastically increases their survival rate.

Also, be aware that many fish medications contain copper, which is lethal to all invertebrates. Always check the ingredients before treating a tank that contains shrimp.

Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Shrimp Keeping: Best Practices

Being a responsible aquarist means thinking about where our animals come from. When it comes to sustainable amano shrimp or ghost shrimp, there are important differences.

Most Ghost shrimp you find in stores are captive-bred in the United States. They have a minimal environmental impact and are a very eco-friendly amano shrimp or ghost shrimp choice.

Amano shrimp, however, are a bit more complicated. They are notoriously difficult to breed in captivity because their larvae require a transition to full saltwater (brackish) to develop before returning to freshwater. Because of this, nearly all Amano shrimp sold are wild-caught from rivers in Japan and Taiwan. While collection is generally regulated, choosing captive-bred species when possible is always the most sustainable option. Supporting reputable retailers helps ensure the shrimp are sourced responsibly.

Frequently Asked Questions About Amano Shrimp or Ghost Shrimp

Can Amano shrimp and Ghost shrimp live together?

Yes, absolutely! They occupy slightly different niches and will generally ignore each other. They can coexist peacefully in the same tank, giving you the benefits of a master algae-eater and a generalist scavenger in one.

How many shrimp should I get for my tank?

For Amano shrimp, a good starting point is one shrimp per 2-3 gallons of water for effective algae control. For Ghost shrimp, you can keep a group of 5-10 in a 10-gallon tank as their bioload (the amount of waste they produce) is very low.

Will my fish eat my shrimp?

It depends on the fish. The simple rule is: if a fish’s mouth is big enough to fit a shrimp, it will eventually try to eat it. Stick to small, peaceful community fish like neon tetras, guppies, corydoras, and otocinclus. Always provide plenty of hiding spots like plants (especially mosses) and driftwood.

Why are my Ghost shrimp turning white and dying?

If a Ghost shrimp turns opaque or milky-white, it’s often a sign of a bacterial infection called muscular necrosis. Unfortunately, this is usually fatal and there is no reliable cure. The best course of action is to remove the infected shrimp immediately to prevent it from spreading to others.

The Final Verdict: Which Tiny Janitor is for You?

So, after our deep dive, the choice between amano shrimp or ghost shrimp comes down to your primary goal.

Choose Amano Shrimp if your main priority is wiping out a stubborn algae problem. They are an investment, but their work ethic is unmatched. They are the algae-busting specialists you call in for the tough jobs.

Choose Ghost Shrimp if you’re on a budget, new to shrimp keeping, or want a general-purpose scavenger to tidy up leftovers and prevent future problems. They are hardy, entertaining, and a fantastic, low-risk introduction to the world of invertebrates.

Ultimately, there’s no wrong answer. Both of these fascinating little creatures bring life, activity, and benefits to a freshwater aquarium. Whichever you choose, you’re taking a wonderful step toward creating a more balanced, clean, and beautiful underwater ecosystem. Now go forth and build your perfect cleanup crew!

Howard Parker
Latest posts by Howard Parker (see all)
Related posts
  • Amano Shrimp Aquascape – How To Create A Stunning, Self-Cleaning
  • Amano Shrimp Laying On Side – A Complete Guide To Molting Vs. Distress